Enduring Mysteries - The shroud of Turin, A deep dive.

Download episode

Summary

Enduring Mysteries - The shroud of Turin, A deep dive. 

Music by Karl Casey @WhiteBatAudio
Please subscribe to our new clips channel here - https://www.youtube.com/Truthseekersclips 
Graphics by Spooky
Content created here by Spectral International, LLC.
Buy me a coffee (or 100) to support the show : https://buymeacoffee.com/truthseekers
Music videos by Simon Fly.
Visit our website here : https://truthseekershow.com
Join our patreon here : https://www.patreon.com/c/stevencambian
Subscribe to our youtube channel here :
http://www.youtube.com/c/truthseekershow
Follow Steven Cambian on twitter : @stevencambian
Join our Patreon : https://www.patreon.com/stevencambian
Donate by paypal : Send a paypal to TRUTHSEEKERSHOW@GMAIL.COM Any amount you wish. Please include your chatroom user id, and any message you would like me to read on air. We read every paypal message we are sent and thank every person who sends any paypal support.
Listen to the audio podcast : https://www.spreaker.com/user/14526799
Email us : TRUTHSEEKERSHOW@GMAIL.COM

Show Transcript

The greetings and salutations friends, and welcome back. We are here tonight to do a few things. Many people throughout the history of our show have asked me to do a show on tonight's subject, which is the Shroud of Turin. But I have very effectively evaded doing a show on this particular subject, and there's a few reasons for that.

First, I was raised Catholic Christian, specifically Catholic, so I'm sure that I have my biases about a lot of this, but those biases may be not what you think. Because I was a very inquisitive young man, and I suppose anybody who knows me knows that I'm very skeptical of paranormal claims and probably always have been. And it didn't matter to me whether it was the gypsy fortune teller saying she could talk to your dead grandmother in our neighborhood, or the Catholic priest that said mass every Sunday, when people claimed miraculous or paranormal supernatural things, I was always very skeptical, and so the Shroud of Tourin has been one of those mysteries, however, an enduring mystery which I can't ever quite make my mind upon. So you know, when people ask me what is my opinion on the shroud, it's in my gray basket, and perhaps it always will be until further scientific studies are done.

So we're going to be going over a great deal. I have so much to share with you. And the other thing we are doing is going back to trying to cover more subjects than personalities or people, because we can see the trouble the covering people can bring, like legal troubles or lawsuit threats or you know, I don't think the Catholic Church or anybody is going to threaten to assume me for expressing my opinions on this subject tonight. Maybe it's a bit safer, Maybe it's a bit you know, less stress.

I don't have to worry about this one or anybody. Well, of course, people are so easily offended, you know, I could say anything. So we'll take a moment to welcome in and recognize the live chat we've got. Sherry is in the live chat.

Tim Curley is here, our wonderful moderator, Arlene and I saw spooky earlier operations shut down. Blazing Mad Trollie troll Troll is here. Jonathan Matten is here, Garagie is here, diaper Fur holding down the kick live chat von Srgen Pig Monster two twenty reel is here one moment here and if I miss you, I apologize. The outer planet is here.

Shout out to the outer planet. Patty Wilhelm is here. Ray Gunner is here holding down the kick chat as well. Sherry is saying she was brought up in the Roman Catholic Church.

Well, we're going to get into this. So when I was younger, I first heard about the shroud of Turin, which purports to be, or alleges some alleged to be the actual burial shroud or cloth of Jesus Christ. And you know, there is historical proof that a man named Jesus in that time general date and region existed and was crucified by the Romans. Some people say otherwise, you know, people will say what they're going to say.

You know, the the Jewish priests handed over Jesus to punsiou his pilot, the you know, I supposed Roman authority in the region who made the actual decision, famously washing his hands of the decision to crucify Jesus Christ. So this this actual it's a linen cloth, and it has a faint image of what appears to be what appears to be naked man with wounds consistent with Roman crucifixion at the time of Jesus. And I'm gonna go on scripts now if nobody minds, because I like to get the facts and the figures correct, and there is so much on this. But before I do that, I'm going to share my screen the best pictures that i've you know, kind of looked all over the internet and I found a few places that have some really good, high quality imagery of the shroud of Turin, And here we can see the image is of the front of a human body that is crossing its arms over the groin area.

There is a tremendous amount of you know, people pointing out things like there are wounds around the head that people say would be consistent with someone being tortured or forced to wear around a crown of thorns. There is a gash or wound on the side of the check, which is consistent with Jesus and the biblical story that he was speared they wanted to make sure he was dead. Their holes through the wrists and feet also consistent with Roman crucifixion practices at the time, although there was many it should be noted, and this is probably a very little known fact, but there were an incredible variation in crucifixion. In crucifixions, for example, some were crucified on an X cross, some on a T cross, some on a capital T cross, and sometimes the people would be tied to the cross, sometimes they would be nailed to the cross.

But what's very interesting about the Shraveturin to me is that it appears that this man depicted in the image was scourged and attacked with Roman whips that are consistent with Roman whips at the time. The wounds that are displayed on the image, i should say, are consistent with scourging weaponry that would be used to scourge a victim in those times. So there is just an incredible amount of things that lead many to believe that this is actually depicting the body of Jesus Christ. But what's incredible to me is that an incredible amount of different scientists, all different disciplines have studied the shroud, and not one of them can tell you with certainty how the image got onto the shroud.

Now there are two different camps I suppose a skeptical camp and the believer camp, or you know, and but both are kind of puzzled as to how the image actually appeared. Doesn't appear that this image was painted on. The image is incredibly thin. It only penetrates the very very top layers of the linen.

But I'm going to go onto my script because i want to make sure that we get the facts and figures correct, and it's important to note. We'll also show you that there is the back image. So basically, the cloth was laid and a body apparently or allegedly was placed on it, and then it was folded over the front side of the body. So this one, the first image, is known as the ventral image or front image, and this website states it is usually viewed horizontally during an exhibition, but the image has been positioned vertically for better viewing.

Large burns and scorch marks from the fire. This relic was in a fire in fifteen thirty two seemed to frame the image. Look for the blood on the arms, nail wounds in the wrist, wound on the side, and blood in the head on the head and hair. Also notice water stains from where the cloth was rolled up and kept in some kind of urn.

A water stain over the knees shows the image is not water soluble. The edges of the water stains are due to calcium deposits, and the back image is known as the dorsal image. Notice the apparent crown of thorns and scorge marks around the crisscross and back of the legs. About one point twenty of such marks can be counted.

There is blood or appears to be blood across the small the back that flowed from the side wound after the body was laid out horizontically after death at the bottom or the feet, one foot placed upon the other and nailed into position. Noticed the nail wounds and corresponding blood flow. Now now we're going to go And interestingly, this was what people were seeing in the cloth before it was first photographed. But once it was photographed first in eighteen ninety eight, that's where the story got stranger in my opinion.

So in eighteen ninety eight, the church finally allowed the shroud of tourn to be photographed for the very first time, and it was an amateur photographer which took the first image. And as the story goes, he went back to his dark room and almost dropped the photoplates, which at the time were glass, because the image in the negative was startling to him. Much more detail was shown in the negative image than would be shown to the naked eye. And this is, like I said, where the story gets strange, because either this is as people believe or suggest as the authentic burial cloth of Jesus.

And some say there was some sort of radiation event when Jesus rose from the dead which caused the image to appear in the cloth. I don't know if that's true or not, but we'll be exploring all of people's theories tonight during this deep dive. But what was interesting is when the photograph was when the when the shroud was first photographed in eighteen ninety eight, an incredible amount of detail, much more then can be seen with the naked eye, could be shown. And it's almost as if the negative is actually the positive of the image.

It appears much more like almost like a photograph. The negative appears almost like a photograph of you know, this crucified man. And as the story goes, the photographer was so shocked by what he saw it almost dropped the plates, believing that he was the first person to see the real face of Jesus in over two thousand years. So this is a just a display, like a laid out copy of what the image looks like when it is in negative form.

Now give me a moment here, because I have some more and more detail of this, of course, is the regular image or positive image, and people have noticed and said that the face looks just like the Jesus that we all know. But it's important to note that I don't believe that there was any like painted depictions of Jesus for hundreds of years after his death. So do we really know that Jesus was, you know, brown haired, bearded? I don't know, but it is interesting what this face appears to be to a Christian that's the face of Jesus, or it appears very strongly that it could be the face of Jesus.

And there's another depiction. So this is a full body of the negative image, which again it shows an incredible amount more detail than you can see with the naked eye. And it's interesting that people were excited about the shroud before the picture, but after the picture is when it really rose to worldwide prominence as an alleged relic of the burial shroud of the biblical Jesus. So let me get back to my script, though, Oh before I do that, let's take a moment to thank some kind and generous benefactors.

We've got Noka forty eight n says Loha friends. I'm here, but I will be driving. I will look forward to the show. I love history.

Thank you Stephen for awesome, awesome work. Well, thank you Noka for your kindness, generosity and support. And with regrets, I apologize, but I'm not going to be playing a lot of stripper bumpers tonight. Just I don't want to talk about Jesus and play stripper bumpers.

To thank people for the super chats tonight, I hope you understand. And Tim Curley is here with one for the goal as well. Thanks Stephen, great topic and I appreciate your deep dive and research. Here another great show as always.

Well, it just started. It might be terrible, and I've noticed we've got pretty low attendance tonight. See what happens when I go off the script, even if I or our usual subject matter. I guess, even when I'm doing something that so many people have asked me to do, and I want to put on the record.

You know, I was raised Catholic, and even when I was a child whether the shroud you could ask I could ask ten different priests and ten different nuns, and ten different priests and ten different nuns would all give me a different answer when I asked them if the shroud of Tourin really is the burial shroud of Jesus. Some believed it is, and some were more skeptical and claimed that it might have been a forgery. Now it's important to note that the historical, you know, chain of custody is very important. So as far as the chain of custody goes, we only know the Shroud of Tourin has been known or existed since the thirteen hundreds, leading many to believe that this is a forgery.

From the thirteen hundreds when religious reliquary or relics were a big financial draw. In other words, people kind of went nuts in Europe and would say, oh, have you been to this church? It has the nails of the crucifixion from what Jesus was crucified in their altar, and other people would have different relics of all different types and these were big tourist draws and therefore a big financial boom to the churches that housed them. So many people think that the shroud was just a created art piece, a fake designed to fool pilgrims so that they could make money off of the tourism and the pilgrims.

But back to back to my script here so that we get things correctly on the record. So the shroud of Tourin is a linen cloth bearing the faint image of a crucified man, or apparently crucified man, and this has captivated scholars, scientists, and the faithful for centuries now. It is often purported to be the actual burial shroud of Jesus Christ. It remains one of the most studied artifacts in history.

Tonight, I'm going to try my best to provide balanced scholarly presentation here and present the strongest arguments for the shroud's authenticity as a first century relic, alongside some compelling evidence suggesting it is indeed a medieval forgery. Now you may know why I can't make up my mind on this one. Key scientific analyses will be explored, including when I think is one of the most important scientific studies of the shroud, the nineteen eighty eight carbon fourteen dating. We'll be discussing that in detail.

Also. You know, I think we can't really cover this without covering the Catholic Church's official stance on the shroud's authenticity. We'll be exploring that along with its economic implications for the church and the city of Turin. Like I said, there's plenty of Taurus dollars to be had, and I believe the last time that the shroud was actually exhibited publicly.

Usually they keep it in a box, a temperature controlled box that I think is even filled with argone gas because it's inert. They're trying to preserve this thing forever. It's not just like hanging up in the church. But when they do display it, hang it up and let people come and see the actual shroud, they draw millions and millions of people.

Now, I will say, to their credit, the Catholic Church doesn't like sell tickets to these events, but you know, if somebody goes there, they're gonna draw. They passed the collection played around, Let's leave it at that. They certainly passed the collection played around to those two million people. So we're gonna really dig deep into some historical records Tonight, some scientific studies, and more modern scientific studies and analyzes.

But really, you know, I titled Tonight's broadcast, uh, you know, enduring mysteries, because this one is one of those. It's just an enigma to me. I really think there needs to be a lot more research into the shroud from a scientific perspective. The problem is that the Catholic Church is the gatekeepers, So just just some more facts and figures.

Is actually a rectangular linen cloth measuring approximately four point four meters by one point one meters, and it features a faint straw. It features faint straw yellow images of the front and back of a naked man with his hands folded over his groin. The figure appears to be bearded with shoulder length hair and wounds that many say are consistent with biblical descriptions of Jesus' crucifixion, including marks on the wrists, feet, side, and forehead. There are reddish brown stains on the cloth that were originally interpreted as blood.

Later I believe later scientific evidence proved that those stains were blood aligned with these crucifixion injuries. The cloth is woven in a three to one herringbone twill pattern from flax fibers and is consistent with burial shrouds consistent with that time period and geographical location. The shrouds showed signs of historical damage, including burn marks from the fifteen thirty two fire, and this was repaired with patches. It is housed in Touring, Italy at Saint John the Baptist Cathedral since fifteen seventy eight.

It has been there. But the shrouds origins really are, especially from a historical perspective, are shrouded in mystery. The documented history of this particular shroud, which, by the way, I just want to make sure we understand that many people try to say that some other historical or effects were actually this rout of touring, but they called it something different, or they thought it was something different. You know, people are trying to fill in the blanks.

I suppose you could say from zero to thirteen th fifty four with other sightings. For example, there was a painting several hundred years before thirteen fifty four that depicted something that looked like the shroud of Tour and people say, well, there's the proof that it existed before thirteen fifty four. It's a bit of a quagmire looking into the history. But the documented history or chain of custody begins in thirteen fifty four in ly Re, France, where it was exhibited by the Knight Jeffrey de Charnay.

Prior to this, there are really no reliable records about the Shroud, although some proponents suggest connections to earlier relics like the Image of Odessa and the Shroud. Since it surface has passed through various owners, including the House of Savoy, before being donated to the Holy See or Catholic Church in nineteen eighty three. Public exhibitions of the actual shroud are very rare, with notable viewings in twenty ten with over two million visitors and twenty fifteen, and there was another planned exhibition for twenty twenty five, but I believe that that has been canceled. The shroud's image which was first revealed to be a photographic negative in eighteen ninety eight by Secundo Pia.

He was the photographer who took the first picture. And by the way, when Secundo Pia took this first picture, everybody said that he faked the picture, that it was some sort of crazy hoax for publicity, but when it was next allowed to be photographed, people found the same result. This incredible image appeared in the negative. The shroud exhibits unique properties that have fueled debates over its authenticity.

Some view the out of touring as some sort of miraculous imprint from Christ's resurrection, like a byproduct of that event. Others see it merely as a cleverl medieval artwork. But tonight we're, like I said, we're going to try to balance these perspectives. I'll be giving you the arguments for authenticity that proponents of the shroud use, and also I'll be giving you a perspective of some of the more skeptical people who have studied this artifact.

So proponents of the Shroud's authenticity argue that it is indeed and could be a lot of people use some strange phrasing too, like it couldn't be anything else other than this the burial cloth of Jesus. And it's interesting to note that much like in the UFO community or in the ghost hunter community, there exists sort of talking points which get repeated ad nauseum, often without proof. So we have to be very careful when we examine the things that people are claiming or saying. But as far as it being an authentic relic from the first century, there are several lines of evidence that support this claim, like the image formation and its properties.

The image is superficial, penetrating only the top two hundred to six hundred nanometers of the fibers, and the shroud has been found to be without pigments, binders, paint, or anything like that. Of course, people still argue this issue, but there is some science to support that there is none of those things. There's no pigments, paint, or you know, medium that could have been used to create you know, I have been studying high resolution images and to me a lot of especially not the negative image, but when you look at it with the naked eye, it really looks to me like it was almost burned into the cloth, not painted into the cloth.

So interesting that we also found out that the image in the shroud actually encodes three dimensional information, and this was demonstrated by image analyzer studies in the nineteen seventies, which suggested that the image may have been formed by contact with a three dimensional object, possibly a body. Years after the nineteen seventies image analyzer studies first noticed that there's actual three D data and information that is embedded into the image. I get when people say, oh, it's a fake, I don't understand even if it's a fake from the thirteen hundred's how somebody knew how to encode three D image information in a two D image. That's another mystery about this whole thing.

So forensic pathologists have looked at the shroud and confirmed the anatomical accuracy of wounds that are consistent with Roman crucifixion of the first century, including nail marks in the wrist and over one hundred and twenty scourge marks from a flagrum. That's what the Romans used to beat or whip prisoners and victims with. It's called a flagrum, and the injuries shown in the shroud are consistent with a Roman flagrum injury that you'd get from, you know, being scourged in the first century by the Romans. And this is very interesting because when people argue that this is a clever forgery or a clever hoax, I just think to myself, there must have been an incredible hoaxer because he was able to track down what a wound from a flagrom in the first century looks like and reproduce it exactly.

There is also some biological and chemical evidence the reddish stains on this shroud contain iron oxide and proteins that are consistent with human blood, including Billie Ruben levels that are indicative of trauma. So this again is consistent with somebody who has been crucified. And one of the most intriguing aspects that people point to as proof that the shroud is authentic is there's actually pollen grains from plants on the shroud of Turin. This has been scientifically proven, and those pollen grains are plants that are native only to the Jerusalem area.

And this is perplexing because again, if we imagine that there's someone in the thirteenth century that's trying to create a hoax burial cloth of Jesus, what they go so far as to figure out exactly what a flagoran wound looks like and reproduce it, And then, you know, I don't understand, do they go to Jerusalem and shake pollen off of plants there and put it on the shroud? Because there is verifiably pollen from plants that are native only to the Jerusalem area, which would be where Jesus lived, you know, was crucified and allegedly buried before many believe that he rose from the dead. There was also a DNA analysis of some of what people believe is blood from the cloth, and this revealed human mitochondrial DNA from diverse ethnic routs compatible with ancient people living in the Near East in the first century.

There was a twenty twenty two wide angle X ray scattering study that analyzed linen degregation and dated the shrial to be somewhere between fifty five and seventy four CE, attributing discrepancies with prior dating to environmental contamination. So proponents argue that the image could result from a burst of radiation during resurrection, and this is just a hypothesis. There's no proof for it, but this is what many people have said. But that hypothesis is supported by some scientific findings that ruled out conventional artistic methods like painting or trying to burn the image into the cloth.

These arguments for the shroud's authenticity or tray the shroud as a relic that defies medieval technology. In fact, many of the proponents of its authenticity claim that no one in the thirteen hundred time period could do this. I beg to differ and we'll see some proof about that. Okay, now on the skeptical side, let me just check them with the live chat before we continue here.

Trolly troll, troll this year with one for the goal. Not that I'm complaining or anything, but I seem to recall you did a show about the shroud once before. Nope, never have, never have. You're confusing it with we did do some shows that I called Christian mysteries, but we've never done a show.

I'm thinking myself, you know, I did just have brain surgery. But no, I'm certain TROLLI troul troll, we did not do a show about the shrout of tour and yet but thank you Troy trot Troeper kindness, generosity and support. Will take a moment to check in with the with the live chat as well. Well.

This is a good question. Why would light from radiation have a beard shape? Yeah? I mean what I have found about this Shroud of Tour in my studies of you know, and I've really really dug deep here to see both sides of the arguments, is you get more questions than answers.

Like I said, when I was a child, I would ask different priests if the shroud was real, and some of them believed absolutely, Stephen, that's from when Jesus resurrected, he left a sign of his resurrection in the cloth. And others would say, no, somebody made it just to make money. You know, believe it or not. Some priests are cynical and skeptical.

That's funny that you should mention that we're chief Reviews. We're going to be getting into some of the other relic claims. And this is why I'm very skeptical of the Catholic Church. And I will explain why.

It's something I like to call the incorruptible bodies scam that the Catholic Church runs. But let me get back to the skeptical side of the arguments one moment here. Okay, So on the skeptical side of the arguments, one second burst of radiation. That's interesting, Okay, So on the skeptical side of things, the shroud's first appearance aligns with the medieval relic trade.

In thirteen eighty nine, Bishop Pierre, the our Sease of Troy's denounced the shroud tour in as a complete and total forgery, claiming that an artist confessed to quote painting it. There is no pre thirteen fifty documentation about the shroud, and a twenty twenty five study from a newly discovered document from philosopher Nicole or Ism reinforces that the shroud has medieval origins, and it's important to note that the medieval relic trade was big business. Like I said, people would each church would have some form of relic. We've got the blood of Jesus in this cross, or we've got you know, the bones of Peter.

They all would claim that they had. For example, some churches claimed that they had a relic that was a piece of wood from the cross that Jesus was crucified on. But if you were to take all of those relics and put them together, you would see that there's enough to make ten crosses out of. So the relic trade is often fraudulent.

Many say, I believe that there are many Catholic relics that are completely and totally fake, And to this day though, they make each of the churches where the relics reside tons of money. So I think a lot of me thinks that the Catholic Church doesn't want to spoil the party when it comes to relics. So there have been some scientific replications and analyzes, including that One of the talking points you'll hear is that nobody can do this, we can't reproduce this, and that's really not the case. Several people have reproduced very very similar imagery on a linen cloth through various means, and apparently the image or one very very much like it can be replicated using techniques that were available in medieval times, such as base relief, rubbing with pigments or acid pigmentation.

Walter mccrone's nineteen seventy eight analysis detected red okra and vermilion pigments in a gelatin medium, suggesting painting. So it wasn't exactly paint, but it was red okra and vermilion pigments in gelatine, a gelatin medium. So this is where things get kind of squirrely, because you have the believer saying we've scientifically confirmed there's no paint. But then in nineteen seventy eight they detected red oakri and vermilion pigments and a gelatin medium on the shroud.

Isn't that pain I think that's pain. It's something just like pain. I don't know. And then, of course, many of the skeptical experts have pointed to anatomical inconsistencies like disproportionate limbs and unnatural blood flows which indicate artistic creation or artistic license and not a natural process being shown here.

Some of the blood flow analysis has been interesting, so it appears that the blood flow shown on the trout is not what would anatomically happen if it was a natural process, which means somebody took some artistic license, you know, and drama made it more dramatic. A twenty twenty five three D analysis was just done suggested that the image actually derives from sculpture, sculpture or base relief. In other words, someone took a sculpture of a body that you kind of can see in the image, and then they put the shroud around it, first pigmenting somehow the sculpture. Then the cloth is placed around it, and the cloth gets an imprint from the sculpture.

And there's a lot of experts that are really positive that this image was created by putting it over a sculpture, not a real human body. And then of course, the most famous argument that skeptics make is the carbon fourteen dating. In nineteen eighty eight, samples from the shroud were tested by laboratories at Oxford, Arizona, and Zurich using accelerator mass spectromity. The results dated the cloth to be aged or from twelve sixty to thirteen ninety CE with ninety five percent confidence, which actually matches its historical debut.

Then when the shroud was the carbon dating dates it to around the time that the shroud first entered history. So challengers challenges include many believers challenged those carbon fourteen results. So in other words, they carbon dated it and it was clearly from medieval times. Somewhere between the studies varied, but somewhere between twelve seventy three and thirteen ninety is what it was dated at.

The challengers to this carbon dating say there were sample contamination from repairs, something like invisible reweaving with cotton, or that fire damage could have created a false a false age once carbon dated, and there is some scientific evidence for that. If the shroud was in a fire, well, there would have been a lot of smoke, and what's in smoke carbon smoke that when the shroud was in the what would be normally a very straightforward test, it could have added carbon and therefore the results of the carbon fourteen analysis could be extremely flawed. Six. But it's interesting to note that no radio carbon expert has invalidated these tests, and the medieval date get given.

It's other people like religious scholars or that raise these arguments, but no actual expert in radiocarbon dating has invalidated those original tests. So skeptics emphasize the shroud's alignment with medieval history artistry and relic forgery practices. It was very common that people would fake relics in order to make money at the exact time that this so called relic entered history, So skeptics argue that authenticity of this actually being the burial cloth of Jesus is very unlikely without additional testing, which would overturn the original carbon dating. It's interesting that the Catholic Church, who could clear all this up by just letting new tests take place, I don't know why they don't do that.

Their stance on authenticity remains in neutral position. The Catholic Church neither in dorses that it's actually the real burial cloth of Jesus, but they don't reject that either. Pope Francis in twenty thirteen says it permits veneration as an object of devotion, viewing it as an icon of a man scourged and crucified. But Pope's Pope John Paul the second and Benedict the sixteenth encouraged scientific study without any actual doctrinal commitment.

In other words, they don't want to commit that yes, this is the burial cloth of Jesus until more scientists study the cloth. The church Catholic Church apparently in trusts authenticating the shroud to be truly a first century relic and therefore quite possibly or probably or the burial cloth of Jesus to science and the Catholic Church for as long as I can remember, remember I was raised Catholic. I mentioned that some priests would tell me it was real, and some priests would tell me it was fake. But there was also people that I would consider fence sitters, and they would say this is still no matter what it is, it's a valuable object because it has a great inspirational value two people and is the source of faith for many.

Now it's important that we talk about the economic impact of the Catholic Church in Turin, because this is where you know, I'm very fond of the saying follow the money. They they the church in which this sorry, the church, the church in which the shroud is kept, has made millions and millions and millions of dollars in donations when people come to visit. So I think there may be some economic factors when we think about this so called relic or holy relic. So of course the shroud significantly boosts tourism and economic activity, particularly during exhibitions, though the Catholic Church does not directly profit from ticket sales, as viewings are free.

But of course, like I said, they're going to pass the collection plate around, and if two million people visit, even if everybody only gives them a dollar in the collection plate, that's a couple million dollars. And this of course stimulates tour in tourings, economic activity, and tourism through hotel bookings, dining related spending, and hotels are always sold out in that whole area when they exhibit this relic. Of course, this provides an unusual bit of economic stimulus to that region. So historically relics like the shroud generate revenue through pilgrimages, donations, and of course local commerce enriching churches and the religions running those churches.

For Turin. The twenty twenty five exhibition that was planned was projected to drive significant growth, contributing to Italy's tourism sector and generate millions of dollars during that event, which, by the way, I believe is canceled. They're not going to exhibit it in twenty twenty five. I try to look into why, and I'm not quite sure why.

And there are some new initiatives like a five million dollars Shroud Museum in California, which opened in twenty twenty five, and that kind of highlights its ongoing economic draw beyond tourin. And it's also interesting to note that besides the Catholic Church, they're not the only people that are cashing in on this thing, because where did it go? There we go. These images are actually taken from a replica that you could buy on Amazon.

That's right, for one hundred and sixty nine dollars, you can have a life size replica of the Shroud of tourin either the positive image or the negative image, whatever you prefer. One moment here. I'll take a moment to catch up with the live chat. Joseph is here with one for the goal, saying sorry about the surgery.

Bro side notes saw the old DSP and T interrogation, I mean interview awesome. As for the shroud, there's so much debate, but I believe. Well, there you go, Thank you, Joseph. I'm still on the fence.

I'm still trying to make up my mind, but maybe I can if I go through enough of the evidence. The Outer Planet is here with one from the goal. I hope you mentioned the face cloth, the Pseudarium of Ovido. Yeah, I am going to because okay, I'll do it right now.

Actually, the outer planet, so there is another cloth as closely tied or associated with the with the shroud of Turin. It's called the Sudarium of Ovito. But it is I don't want to say more, I don't want to say less exciting. That's probably the proper term for it.

Though. It just looks like blood splotches on an old cloth that's, you know, much smaller than the shroud. You know, it's it's a few feet by a few feet, and that relic does trace back to I think the fifth century BC. They have a chain of custody for it from the fifth century BC forward.

And it's interesting people say that the Sudarium of Ovito was placed over Christ's face and then removed and sopped up a lot of blood, and then the shroud was then placed over the body. And interestingly, many people believe that when you line up the Sudarium of Ovido over the head image on the shroud of Turin, that the blood and wounds match up. I'm not sure what I believe about that, but it is interesting that when you get into the blood analysis, it's the same blood or blood type. They haven't DNA matched it to each other, but it's the same blood type on both the Shroud of Turin and on this other face cloth, this other relic, the Sudarium of Ovito, And that to me is very very interesting.

So thank you the outer planet and all of our kind and generous benefactors. We'll catch up with the live chat. Yeah, tampon blood magic. I want DNA tests on the cloth where they found that there is DNA in the blood and the blood.

The blood evidence get very interesting as well, because there appears to be pre mortem blood on the cloth and post mortem blood or I'm sorry, post mortem blood on the cloth and pre mortem blood. So in other words, that means that there was blood from a living person. Somebody was alive when the blood from that person was deposited on the cloth, and there is then blood from someone who is deceased that is also shown on the cloth. I don't know how these Einstein's figure that out, but they did an orthodoxy.

It's called the icon made without human hands. That's interesting. Yeah, so one moment, let me get back to my notes here. So just to wrap up this section, and we have a few more sections to share with you.

The rout of Torn to Me embodies a profound intersection of faith, science, and history. Arguments for its authenticity highlight its inexplainable image and potential ancient origins, bolstered by some recent scientific studies. Conversely, Carbon fourteen dating and historical evidence strongly support that this is indeed a medieval forgery, with controversies surrounding it. The Catholic Church's agnostic stance about the shroud allows for interpretation and personal devotion without dogmatic assertion, whilst exhibitions yield substantial economic benefits for touring and the church housing the shroud to tourism and donations.

I truly believe that there needs to be a great deal more of future research, perhaps involving non destructive redating, and that may resolve some of the lingering debates. And also I believe that the Catholic Church should allow new carbon fourteen dating, and this time it should be performed by maybe six separate universities or experts in these matters, and there should be no doubt when the second testing is done. People have been trying to poke holes, I believe, into the first carbon fourteen dating since nineteen eighty eight. And I remember when that carbon fourteen dating came out in nineteen eighty eight.

It was in I believe, there was a story in a Time magazine, and my father was big, big into you know, we got Popular Science, Time Magazine, Popular Mechanics, and a few others. And I remember when the carbon fourteen dating in nineteen eighty eight came out, I felt like I finally had an answer, Oh okay, it's a fake. But recent recent, I suppose recent reignited interest in some doing more science on this strange thing called the Shroud of Turin has kind of reignited many people's curiosity, including my own. You know, maybe the carbon fourteen was off.

People have suggested that they took a piece of one of the patches. I think this is very easy to clear up. And what's frustrating about all this debate about the carbon dating is that the Catholic Church could give out, you know, like a one inch single strand of thread from this relic, and then we could clear up all of the all the confusion and all of the arguments and doubt about the original dating. So there really does need to be an incredible amount more research.

But it's interesting to me, just interesting to me, just how many scientists are taking the scientific study of this relic or artifact incredibly seriously. So there's a great deal of research on the bloodstains, and I have some more on the pollen. But before we get to that one moment here, before we get to that, we'll catch up with the live chat. Have China clone the blood sample, you know, if they could get that, that's where this gets even it gets kind of strange as a story.

I've often thought that what if they could get They apparently did get mitochondrial DNA from what appears to be blood on the shroud, and what if that really is the blood of Jesus and they clone them and then that's the Antichrist. Right, interesting idea, at least for a movie. Right. So we're going to talk for a moment about why I don't trust the Catholic Church when they claim they have something paranormal or miraculous.

And I've got a great personal story to share with you about that one moment here. Okay, So there's a big reason that I don't trust the Catholic Church when it comes to what they tell me about miraculous things or supernatural things. This is the body of Saint John Newman. It is in the cathedral of Saint John Newman in Center City, Philadelphia.

Anybody remembers stand By Me? You remember that movie stand by Me? Hey want to go see a dead body? So we had during our religious classes, we had a class and one of the classes was all about Saint John Newman.

Saint John Newman, that is his purported to be his body in the bottom of this altar in his cathedral in Center City Philadelphia. He had something that people call, or Catholics would call, an incorruptible body. And so essentially one of the proofs that a saint is in heaven or is a saint. Before someone is canonized as a saint, they exhume the body.

They exhume the body, and there's strange because there's all different criteria, but apparently if the body is in a certain condition, they declare the body to be incorruptible, like it doesn't rot. It's perfectly preserved, not mummified, but perfectly preserved. And what you will find if you dig into this very morbid. First of all, I think it's morbid to put a dead body on display in a church.

But you know, when I was a child, I was like, wait, so this guy's body is in the church in a glass box and you could just go look at it. And the priest teaching me Clas, said, yeah, anybody can go and see it. And I was like, is that his real body? Father, And yeah, that's his real body.

And I at that point, I was very young. I don't think I'd ever seen a dead body before. So, you know, being a curious young man, I got some bus fare and I went down to the cathedral of Saint John Newman to see that this body that apparently was in perfect condition and had not decayed. And I got to tell you it was it was a pretty disappointing experience because what happened is I was altar boy, so I wasn't afraid of like walking around a Catholic church or up on the stage or on the altar.

And I walked right up. I went into the cathedral and it was I don't know, mid morning, maybe ten am, and there was nobody there. And this was on a Saturday, and the weather, as I recall, was terrible. It was like really cold and rainy, like icy rain.

So there's nobody around. And I'm looking around the church and there's nobody around, and I went to the first pew, the closest that I could get without going up on the stage, and I'm looking at this thing, and I'm going, that's not a real body. It can't be a real body. And so eventually I got up the carriage.

I looked around again, and I walked right up to this thing and put my nose right in the glass, right at this guy's head, and I'm looking at it, and I'm looking looking at it, and I go, that's a mask. That's not a that's not a person's face. And then all of a sudden I was startled because a priest had come into the church from the side door or something and startled me, young man, you're not allowed up there, and I'm like, good Catholic boy, like, oh, I'm sorry, father. I just had to see it close up.

I came all the way here on the bus and everything to see Saint John Newman. And so the priest stopped to talk to me for a few minutes and I said, that's not a real face, and he said, no, it's it's it's a wax mask. What what do you mean, it's a wax mask. It's supposed to be incorruptible.

Well yeah, but you know we uh, they use a wax mask. And I'm like, well, there is the rest of them preserved. Why do you need the mask if his face is and his body is perfectly preserved. And he explained, you know, all these different reasons for why they do that.

I don't know, but I look back at it again this time sure that what I was seeing was a mask. So it turns out, if you really dig into this and this is a morbid subject, they basically just build a wax dummy around this person's skeleton, and then they tell everybody that the body does not rot, it's incorruptible, which the term incorruptible is kind of a kind of a stupid it's kind of a stupid thing. One moment though, I have a video about this. So this is why I'm skeptical of any church, especially the Catholic Church, making claims.

They might ask yourself, why would they do that? Fake a body? And again, it's money. Every year people go to on pilgrimages to Saint John Newman's Cathedral.

They make a lot of money. They make a lot of money, a lot a lot of money. One moment here, I might getting tripped up here. I have a video about the incorruptible bodies, and I get it that this is kind of off the beaten path, right, But you know what, Before we do that, I want to share this video about the three D information that is encoded, and we'll put our fair Use banner up.

This is a transformative work. We're educating the public. We'll be critiquing the video that we're sharing and discussing it with our live chat. This is fair use friends.

One moment here, so there's a man named Ray downing who is a three D CGI artist. And when he heard and realized that there was three D information that was embedded in the Shroud of Touring image, he became intrigued and he wondered if he could take the data from the three D information that is encoded in the shroud and create a model of the true face of the man from the cloth. And this is where it gets interesting. And by the way, if you just Google, not Google, if you use YouTube search bar, just put in Shroud of Touring, you will find this.

There was a documentary that was called The Face of the Real Face of Jesus. Now they're calling it something else, but it's on YouTube. You could watch it for free. Very very interesting and informative.

Peace on the Shroud of Touring end on this person Ray Downing. It's been shrouded in mystery for almost two thousand years. The true face of Christ. In all of human history, no other faces as recognizable as the face of Jesus.

No one knows what Jesus actually looked like. Now for the first time, modern technology science. So here we see religion come together. I wasn't quick enough on the still the Face of Christ.

So that's that is a depiction of how the shroud was placed around the body, which I think is very important so that we can see. Christ in a chapel in Turin, Italy, encased in bulletproof glass. Is the most studied object in the world, the shroud of Turin. I don't know that that's an accurate statement.

The most studied object in the world. I will say that I believe it's really like thousands of scientists has studied this thing. So maybe this ancient cloth bears the image of a tortured and crucified man. Some believe this artifact to be the actual burial shroud of Jesus, the face of the man in the shroud.

And here we see a close up image of what a here's to be. The face in the shroud was scarcely visible until us startly. And here's the negative version of it. So that's a much better view.

And isn't it incredible? Like that looks like a photograph to me, It really looks like a photograph when the negative images is shown shrouded in mystery. Yes, all right, one moment here No one, two, three, ABC with one for the goal saying praise the cast, thank you for your kindness. And I hope you all forgive me.

I don't want to be talking about Jesus and playing stripper bumpers tonight, so we'll save the strippers for another night. Try to be a serious, studious, research based show for once. Thank you for your kindness, generosity and support. Much much appreciated.

One second, so this is a close up where you can really see like it looks like a photograph. It looks like a photograph of a face. How did a medieval artist get that image on that cloth? And how did they know that years later something called photography would be invented.

And when you negative the image, you'll get the startling view of it looking like a photograph of a man. It's pretty pretty interesting to me. The photographic negative was produced. But there is an additional inexplicable property of this image which caught the attention of three D computer graphics artist Ray Downing.

Yeah, and look at that. So when they pull the image and the three D data, Ray Downing is this artist. He has said that it's almost like there's instructions for creating a mold embedded in the image, which I think is pretty interesting. And now I just want to be sure that We're clear there wasn't a he even Ray Downey would admit there wasn't a complete data set.

They were only able to extrapolate so much three D information from the image on the shroud. And then of course they have to use some artistic license. For example, they had to figure out the eyebrows, which weren't clear in the three D data or weren't it wasn't pristine enough to know exactly the shape and with and everything, so they had to use some artistic license when creating this three D rendered face of what appears to be the man in the shroud. But still it's still pretty interesting what they were able to do from the three D information that they could get from the actual image.

Encoded within the fibers of this cloth is three D information which shouldn't be there. It's as if someone using an unknown technology hit a blueprint for constructing a three dam in statue within this two dimensional image. That's very interesting. Go back to that here see the.

Internal statue within this two dimensional image. And like I said, Ray Downing has said, it was almost like they encoded instructions for making a mold of the face, a negative mold of the face in the image in two dimensional image. Extracting and refining this encoded information to create that statue. So that's some incredible dedication.

The guy spent a year of his life to see what he believed to be the. Face of Jesus, to reveal for the first time, and here is the results of that work, face of the man. In the Shroud. This new portrait of Jesus drew worldwide attention in the news media.

And yeah, this guy, this was a big worldwide story when originally this person Ray Downing, and I believe he did it with the you know, some funding from the History Channel. They of course made a documentary about. The subject of a History Channel special inspired by quotes from the New Testament. Downing has gone on to illustrate a library of Jesus portraits based on the Shroud of Turine image, a face both hidden and Yeah.

So after the initial extraction and building of it, then he went on to make like a whole gallery of artistic more. I think artistic renderings of the face from the shroud. Field in time suffer little children and forbid them not to come unto me. Lazarus come forth.

So these are artistic depictions of stories from the Bible, but using the face that was extracted from the shroud of Turin. Oh, my father, if it be possible, let this cup pass from me. World hates you. You know that it hated me before it hated you.

So he named each of the paintings or artistic works after one verse of a Bible to in the New Testament. Spirit. Greater love hath no man than this, that a man laid down his life for his friends. I am the resurrection and the life.

My kingdom is not of this world. All right, Well we get through that, and I have a few more bits to share with you for this, for this evening. Now I have to say, there's just so much to go through that you could never do it. I'd be here for twelve hours.

So we might do a part two, maybe a part three as I sift through all of the data. The deep dive will continue. But one moment here, how did I not I didn't upload the one file to my Google drive. Let me get that right now.

One second. So there's a very interesting there's a very interesting YouTube channel which is run by an actual funeral director, a mortician, and she was very interested about those incorruptible bodies, as was I one moment here. Oh wait, let me just I don't want to not mention her incorruptible bodies. She's one of the first search results.

This mortician has a couple million subscribers. She talks about morbid stuff. Kind a gothic girl, ah and a mortician. Let me get that before we share the video.

How to tell if your Saint is incorrupt is the Yeah. So her name is Caitlin Doherty the ou g h t y or doty Caitlin Doty, and she made an interesting video and this again is why I have doubts about Let's give that a few minutes here. I want to share some of the more skeptical side of the story as well, because there's many people like I said, that use talking points like they couldn't have done this in the thirteenth century, and that that is apparently not the case at all. So and is also somebody appears to have proved that the shroud of Tourin wasn't laid on a human body, but rather a sculpture, a modeling study suggests.

So we'll share that. I don't know one moment here, so some of the talking points of the true believers get kind of ripped apart as people perform experiments. In a study published Monday July twenty eighth in a Journal of Archaio Mtry, Brazilian three D digital designer Cicero Morez, who specializes in historical facial reconstruction, used modeling software to compare how the cloth drapes over a human body versus how it drapes over a low relief sculpture of one. The image on the shroud of Tourin is more consistent with a low relief matrix.

More As told Live Science in an email. Such a matrix could have been made out of wood, stone, or metal and pigmented or even heated only in the areas of contact, producing an observed pattern. He said, So here is a sort of three D illustration of how the shroud could have been placed over a sculpture of a body to create the image somehow, And according to this digital artist, this is more consistent. The image on the shroud is more consistent with being placed over a statue or a created sculpture rather than an actual human body.

So, and I suppose low relief would mean it would be kind of flatter. So a three D body would create a different sort of an image apparently than a low relief sculpture would. I just thought that was pretty interesting part of the story. So when people say it's definitely from being placed over a human body, the jury's out even on that.

And one of the other skeptical takes that I thought was incredibly important is that, you know, people have said, and like I said, it's not a fact but rather a talking point. People have said that this could not have been produced in the thirteenth century. They just didn't have the technology to do it. And here from NBC News Italian scientists again this is fair use reproduces the shroud of Tourin.

An Italian scientists said he has reproduced the shroud of Tourin, a feat that he says proves definitively that the linen some Christians revere as Jesus christ burial cloth is indeed imity fake. So on the left we have the image from the actual shroud of Turin and on the right here it's pretty close is an image that this person created. An Italian scientist said he has reproduced the shroud of Tourin. The article states the fact that he says proves definitively that the linen some Christians revere as Jesus christ burial cloth is in fact a medieval fake the shroud, and they give the measurements.

Here bears the image eerily reversed, like a photographic negative of a crucified man, which some believers say is Christ. And the scientist goes on to say, we have shown that it is possible to reproduce something like which has the same characteristics as the shroud. Luigi Galisachio galisatio e Lee, who is due to illustrate the results at a conference on the paranormal this weekend in northern Italy. The scientists is a professor of organic chemistry at the University of Pavia.

He made available to Reuter's the paper he will deliver and the accompanying comparative photographs so to get the image. Scientists have been at a loss to explain how the image was left on the cloth. Garla Shelley reproduced the full size shroud using materials and techniques that were available in the Middle Ages. They placed a linen sheet flat over a volunteer and then rubbed it with a pigment containing traces of acid.

A mask was used to create the face. The pigment was then artificially aged by heating the cloth in an oven and washing it, a process which removed it from the surface but left a fuzzy, half tone image similar to that on the shroud. He believes the pigment on the original shroud faded naturally over the centuries. Then they added blood stains, burnholes, scorches, and water stains to achieve the final effect.

Well, that's problematic because there is historical evidence that the shroud was in a fire. But okay. The Catholic Church does not claim the shroud is authentic, nor that it is a matter of faith, but says it should be a powerful reminder of Christ's passion. Gallicel.

This guy's name is something else. Garla Shelley, the scientist, expects people to contest his findings. If they don't want to believe the carbon dating done by some of the world's best laboratories, they certainly won't believe me, he said. The accuracy of the nineteen eighty eight carbon dating tests were challenged by some hardcore believers, who said restorations of the shroud in past centuries had contaminated the result.

The history of The shroud is long and controversial. After surfacing in the Middle East and France, it was bought by it Italy's former royal family, the Savoys, to their Seat and Touring in fifteen seventy eight. In nineteen eighty three, ex King Umberto the Second bequeathed it to the late Pope John Paul. The shroud narrowly escaped destruction in nineteen ninety seven when a fire ravaged the Garne Chapel of the Touring Cathedral where it is held.

The cloth was saved by a fireman who risked his life. Garla Shelley received funding for his work by an Italian association of atheists and agnostics, but said it had no effects on the result. Money has no odor. This was done scientifically.

If the church wants to find me in the future here I am. So that's interesting that he was able to produce a pretty good reproduction of something like the Shroud of Touring, and he did it with totally with things that would be available during the thirteenth century. So just be warned that when you hear people technology to do this and things like that, you know, I don't really like people stating things as facts when there's no evidence to support those facts, and there is actually some evidence that dispute that this could be done in the thirteenth century, because here we have a pretty good reproduction of something like the Shroud of Tourin. It was done in a very low tech way, and so could the Shroud of Tourin have been created in the thirteenth century.

It looks like it looks like it could have been. But I'd be interested to see if the reproduction has the same three D data embedded in the image or not. Certainly looks pretty similar to the original Shroud of Turin image negative. Okay, so we're going to go to back to incorruptible bodies and why I don't trust most things that the Catholic Church says.

So we mentioned this mortician and her channel is Caitlin Dodie the O U G H T Y and it's Kitlin c A I T L I N. I'll add a link to this video and the description of our video. She's got an interesting channel if you're morbid like me. So this is her talking about these incorruptible incorruptible bodies.

And as we watch these videos, maybe you my viewers, will understand that when somebody says this is paranormal or this is supernatural, I don't believe them. And there's reasons why, because we can catch them faking things, literally scamming the public with completely fake claims like this body doesn't decay. Okay, I beg to differ, right, so along with my you know, I would truly love to believe that that was really the burial cloth of Jesus. But carbon dating bothers me a great deal.

The fact that it arrived right when everybody was going relic crazy in the Middle Ages there, you know, in Europe, and it was such a big business, these fake relics. It makes me incredibly skeptical of the claims that people make. And then again, just because someone is a priest doesn't mean that they are immune to I don't want to say lying, embellishing, or just believing something on faith rather than science. So let's take a look at this video and keep in mind that the church has been delaying the inevitable scientific research into the shroud, and I think they have a vested financial interest to keep it open.

Well, it may be real, it may not be real. The science that determined that it was in the thirteenth century may have been flawed. We don't know, it may have been contaminated. Results.

They like to keep it open ended so that the mystery, I think, remains, and so does the money flowing into this church in Tourin, where the Shroud of Tourin is housed. But here's just a quick look into some of the claims that the Catholic Church makes that are completely totally provably bullshit. Lelis died in sixteen fourteen at age sixty four. And look at him now, looking fabulous for a guy who just turned four hundred and sixty five.

Yeah, that looks pretty good for a guy who just turned four hundred and sixty five. And again they say that this person is a saint and that his body is incorruptible, which to most Catholic means it doesn't rot, it doesn't decay, it's perfectly it stays perfectly preserved forever, which is kind of a strange thing. And for those that are not Catholic, there are I don't know, there's got to be probably fifty, maybe last twenty five at the least different churches which have these bodies of saints somewhere in their church, and they are a site. They are a source of revenue.

People come on pilgrimages to see these incorruptible bodies. But as in the case of Saint John Newman, all is not what is claimed. Saint John Newman they claimed has an incorruptible body. It's a wax mask.

But this one is one of the best examples of the bakery. In my opinion. You're going to say that this saint is in heaven and his body's incorruptible and it doesn't decay or rot or you know, stink. I don't know, Am I right?

He's incorrupt, as fresh as the day he died, thanks Catholicism. Wait, I don't mean to be a negative fancy here, but he doesn't really look miraculously incorrupt. And by the way, I just want to mention that we are sharing this video to educate the public. This is a transformative work.

We're educating the public, and we're going to thank Dame seven two four four for a two dollars super chat. How much of the three D rendering is artistic license? Well, you can watch the full documentary. From what I remember, they took an artistic license with eyebrows and eyelashes that I'm aware of.

But I think much of what we see in the completed image is basically the data and you know, information that was embedded in the cloth image itself. So if that's all they did was figure out the eyebrows and the eyelashes, and the rest is more or less accurate to the image on the cloth, I think they did an excellent job. But thank you Dave seventy two four four for her kindness, generosity and support. Let's continue here.

He kind of just looks like a guy made out of wax. If only I knew an incorrupt corpse expert, Oh I do. This girl's got an incorruptible corpse expert as a friend. That's pretty interesting.

And she's a mortician. National relic hunter. Welcome. Hi.

So Saint Camillis, like, what's. Up with him? Well, when I saw him in Rome, the Sacristan, the guy who's in charge of all of the relics, said he was incorrupt. But then he unlatched a compartment underneath the body and Saint Camillis's full skeleton was laid out inside.

So wait, so the whole body is fake and they have his body and by the way that skeleton I don't believe is normally displayed. I think they cover the skeleton and just show you the wax portion. But I could be wrong. I have not been to Rome or this exact church.

I've seen images both ways, with the skeleton not shown, and with the skeleton with the paddle removed and the skeleton underneath the wax fake body displayed. I knew it Saint Camilla's wax, dude, But that doesn't mean he's not incorrupt. You can't judge a Catholic corpse by its cover. Okay, so help us understand what is the concise definition of an incorrupt corpse?

And that's the problem. There really isn't a definitive, concise explanation of what an incorrupt corpse is. And it really if you're Catholic, it depends on who you ask. There's no concise definition.

Will then let's talk the list. How long is it? How many are there? There's no list either?

Well, then how is that even a title? Well, everyone who's even considered for sainthood has to be exhumed and examined as part of the canonization process. Yeah, that's more bid. Like we're going to make you a saint, but first we have to dig up your body and check out how you're doing dead.

So you're a. Potential saint, maybe going to be a saint. And I exume you what am I looking for? No rot at all?

Are you supposed to be life like? Our modern guidelines for what's acceptably incorrupt come from Pope Benedict the fourteenth in seventeen thirty four. So the guidelines were set in seventeen thirty four. It surprise you, but the most important word he used to describe the incorrupt wasn't lifelike.

It was flexible. So if they dig up your dead body and they're going to canonize you as a saint, if your body is flexible, that's good enough for them. And thank you, Humboldt Honey for your kindness, generosity and support. Love these topics.

Do Saint Germain next? I just may do that. But the problem, Humboldt Honey, is that we get less. We get half the support for these kind of more serious shows and half the attendance, you know, But we'll do our best.

I did have sort of a series of Christian mysteries and Saint Germaine would certainly fit into that. Thank you for your kindness, generosity, and support and for being a member. Thanks to all of our members for supporting the broadcast. I'm finding no preservation allowed, so if you'd like to play along, I brought a game tell me more.

It's called incorrupt or Nah. First, since they're not and by the way, just a warning, you know, some of these are truly like bizarre, Like there's some that you just look like a dead, rotting body. It's weird when you go down this incorruptible Bodies rabbit hole. And by the way, if you search our archive, we've done an entire video before just on this subject, the incorruptible bodies.

I just wanted to throw this in because this is why I don't trust when the Catholic Church says something is a relic. By the way, there's lots of proven, completely and totally provably fake relics. I just wanted to throw this in to sort of display why I don't trust when when the church says something is supernatural or paranormal, not Catholic Saints. Here's some naz right off the bat let in nash Bog Bodies nah Rosalie Lombardo, the famous doll like Mommy from the competion crips nash Okay, hit me with my first body, Catherine.

Yeah, like, I said, that's morbid. Why don't they bury that woman and let her rest in peace? She's she's like being displayed in a church like a carnival Ya. Incorrupt or?

Nah? Okay, I know, Saint Catharine. I just did a video about her and there was all sorts of weird miraculous preservation stuff around her. So I'm going to say incorrupt nah.

In nineteen ninety eight, Italian pathologists Issil Boucare from the University of Genoa studied this group of medieval female saints, all thought to be incorrupt. But they'd had organs removed, they were stuffed with herbs, and they had resin rubbed into their skin. Everyone was so concerned with modesty that no one ever fully examined them. Yeah, so that's interesting.

They're taking steps to preserve the skin with different oils and things. That's not a naturally non decaying body in my opinion. In my view, if you have to do anything, I don't think that it should qualify. But the Catholic church plays pretty fast and loose with the requirements for sainthood and for a saint be considered having an incorrupt body or not.

So today they're no longer considered incorrupt. Okay, zero for one, Caitlin, next one. Okay, Saint Paula Frascinetti. This is another one.

Look at that's morbid. They just have this thing on display like it's a circus or a carnival. Incorrupt or nan, so her skin looks preserved. It is with carbolic acid, all right, so.

No preservation allowed at all. That would make this one a Nah. It's incorrupt once. Yeah, it's incorrupt.

When they first opened up Saint Paula's tomb. Twenty look at this girl too, she's like taking taking selfies near the dead people nice. Four years after her death, she was looking great and the nuns of her order were thrilled, so thrilled that they had her preserved in carbolic acid. But since this happened after the discovery of her body, she's still considered incorrupt, is that you?

And so they preserve the body with carbolic acid. They dug it up and it looked pretty good. I really, I'm at a loss for this whole, this whole thing, and why they would do these kind of things, like it's morbid to me. Let him be buried and rest in peace, not be gaukd at for are they just going to leave him in there forever and they'll be gualkd at for hundreds or thousands of years?

And Saint Paula, yeah, definitely is a nun took the picture. It's fine, she insisted to her. Yeah, you don't say no to a non zero to two. Saint Julian Imard in Paris that now that looks like another wax body.

It's super creepy. That has to just be wax. So that isn't that is a knap, That is an Now he's incredible, he. Is, he's incorrupted, just like Saint Paula.

His church also tried to bathe him in carbolic acid, but it completely backfired and destroyed his body. So the body was destroyed, but they still have it on display somehow. But what's now left of him is encased in this terrifying way epigy that makes it look like he's been buried alive. Sure makes me feel pious.

St. Anthony of Padua Inca. Oh, this one's interesting. So sometimes it's not an entire body that they declare and corrupt, just a part of the saint, like the head or different pieces as we'll see here.

Or nah, is that a body part? Yeah, that's his tongue. Okay. If this game has taught me.

Anything so far, it's that I have to just go against every instinct that I have. So I'm going to say that this is an incorrupt tongue. You're right, it's a hat, I mean, correctably, one part is incorrupt. Well, the rest he composes normally.

Yeah, so that's interesting. Sometimes they just say the heart of that saint is incorrupt, but the rest of the body is just rotting away as a normal human body would. This is exactly what happened to St. Anthony of Padua when his coffin was open.

Only as tongue survived intact, so it was detached and put on display in a reliquary. Points on the incorrupt detached tongue. Thank you? Ready for the lightning round?

Bring it? Here are two skeletons wearing clothes, which one is incorrupt, the. One on the bottom, No, the one on the top is. The incorrupt skeleton of Saint Francesca Romana.

Okay, two brown leather. Yeah, these look like mummies. These two. These do not look like anything miraculous.

It looks like you just put a body on a seat or standing up on a stand and let them just rod away inside your church or cathedral or whatever. Very bodies. Which one is incorrupt? Well, the one on the left is in a box, which makes me think she's more important.

So the one on the left, correct, I'm. Okay, last one ready? Two wax bodies. This one is extra confusing because they're in the same church.

So which one is incorrupt? So this church has two of these bodies? Awesome, hat, You're. So right.

Incorrupt, not me being bitter because I lost or anything. But if it's so random, why is this even still a criteria for sainthood. Well, this is a big reason why the church doesn't consider incorruptibility a miracle anymore. It used to be that if you were found incorrupt, that could help you become a saint, But today there are just too many padre of those natural explanations for finding bodies in this state.

So incorruptibility has been downgraded from miraculous to a favorable sign. A favorable favorable sign. All right, you're incorrupt. That doesn't mean you're a saint, but it doesn't hurt basically, Well, thank you for coming by to clear nothing up.

Elizabeth. You can find more of her photographs and writing on her fantastic blog. All the Saints you should know, and you should know them. You should, unlike me, who apparently knows none of them.

Brought to you the support from People's Memorial Association and the all. Right, so I guess I've proved my point with that video. I don't I don't trust when they say something is miraculous, because I don't think there's anything miraculous about these these so called incorrupt bodies. We'll take some questions and comments from the lab chat at a little more time to share with you.

The only thing that the Shroud proves is that the Roman Empire killed lots of people, kind of like every empire that has existed to this day. Well, that's a very good point, right, And Sherry says it does look like a photograph Stephen left eye, thrashed, knocked out. Yeah, that's some of those bodies don't look so good. Right, Some of those bodies do not look incorrupt to me.

They don't look good at all. All right, one second, I'm catching up to the live chat. I'm way behind. Apparently you guys are chatting away in there.

And before I forget, please do take a moment to like, comment and subscribe here. It really does help. Hit that subscription. But hit that subscribe button, tap the notification bell.

You'll know when we're doing one of these deep dives. And this is just the first of probably many shows on this subject we're going to go through. I have so many folders here. Have you looked into eucharistic miracles?

Yes, and that's another one that I think. There's a lot of fraud and stupidity when it comes to that. Stephen is a scholar of theology. Yeah, a lot of people don't know this, but I almost became a priest, and I spent some time at Saint Charles Seminary before deciding that the priesthood was not for me.

Sam Corbyn is reminding everybody to hit the like button. True secret show. Are you an atheist? No?

I am what most people would call an agnostic. I don't believe in atheism because I just look, I just can't wrap my mind around this universe being so perfect and they're not being at least intelligent design that went into the universe, which would mean there would have to be a designer or what many people would call God. People are mentioning a Catholic church scandal. How many boys?

Yes, the sedlak ostuary. Oh that's another interesting I'm a good Catholic. I'm no longer a Catholic. I stopped being Catholic for various reasons, but most of them are because I think that the Catholic Church is all about money, and they have proved that to me time and time again.

I told this story many times, but a quick version is when my father died. He was in hospice for six months, and then the funeral director called me and said, the church said that they can't do the Mass or give you a priest to bury him. And I was like, what's going on. He's been in that church for fifty years, like he's volunteered there.

Everybody knows who he is, Like, so I have to go to the rectory and I find out they decided he wasn't a Catholic and good standing because he hadn't been to church for six months, they said, and I said, how do you know that, Well, we haven't gotten a church envelope from him. So the long story short, I had to pay twenty dollars a week or something for six months, and then suddenly he was a good Catholic again and they could do the mass and bury um. It was right then that I decided that I'm not gonna support a church that treats people like that. My father had volunteered at that church for many, many years.

He was well known, respected and loved, and for the church to slap my family in the face while we were grieving like that, it didn't sit well with me. And famously I went to the ATM machine and I got out the cash, and I went back to the rectory and I literally threw it in the face of the priest and said, you call that funeral director back as soon as I walk out of here and you finish making the arrangements, you're going to bury my father or you and me and everybody in this rectory are going to have a big fucking problem. And I did drop an f bob, and interestingly, a different priest came to bury my father, and he was as nice and can be as could be, and he did apologize for the misunderstanding. But by that point the damage is done right and Patty Wilhelm says the cash.

Yes, that's interesting, Tolie Toldtul says, I went to a Quaker school, and that's what's wrong with America and the world. Yeah. I wasn't treated properly. And it was more just my father died rather unexpectedly.

He was in. He was in. They were talking about moving him to like a rehab hospital and that he would more fully recover and even come home. So we were very hopeful that his medical condition was improving, and then he just kind of died suddenly one night.

So it was unexpected and you know, very difficult time. And this priest basically shaking me down for money at a time like that, I was so pissed, and I remained pissed for many years. And then I gave them another chance even after that one, and then the next thing was even worse that they did to my family. So I just said, I hope your church, I said to myself, and I know this is probably sinful and not a good Christian thing, but I remember thinking, I hope your church burns down and you all lose every every financial resource.

You have. Something else. Favorite song of twenty twenty five, I don't know. I'm not real big on newer music.

I would have to say my favorite album that I started listening to heavily in twenty twenty five was Ozzy Osbourne Patient number nine. I think it's an incredible album, and I just wish there was more OZSI albums. But rest in peace, the Prince of Darkness. Thank you for your kindness, generosity and support.

Von Schrgan is here with one for the goal. And it would be a terrible show host if I didn't go and check in with the Kickchat. And I apologize to the Kickchat kind of. When I have to do these longer presentations with all of these different data points, it's very difficult to keep up with the show host stuff, so I apologize.

Tampon Blood Magic said a rage quit. Thank you for that. And I was going to call out some subs or some gifted subs, but it looks like we are doing just okay here. We're all caught up on that.

But please do support us of our own kick if you like the streams and want us to continue streaming there. Kick is a tremendous resource for people like me because it gives us an extra paycheck in the month and everybody imagine getting five paychecks for the month next week instead of next month, instead of four. Kick really does help us with some extra money. And finally, a lot of people have asked me about this Corey Good situation.

It's been since December seventh, and I'm still waiting on YouTube to try to resolve the false copyright claims and issues. But I will put on the record that it's pretty ridiculous because mister Good has made many false Here's what I'll say. He's made many false and defamatory statements in writing, which is a real problem. Like the guys of Moron, he doesn't understand what he just did.

He put in writing in these copyright takedown requests that the videos on my channel were stolen and that I've stolen other videos and that he called the police on me. Well, all of those statements are demonstrably easily proven false. So is it any surprise to me? And by the way, for those unaware those are legal filings and knowingly make making false statements in writing in that legal filing is considered perjury.

And this is where we're at. This guy is so stupid that he's telling people I stole videos and I stole other videos, and that the police have been called on me. Well, we seem to recall another person who claimed I was a criminal. That would be his one time partner, David Wilcox.

So it doesn't surprise me that somebody like Corey Good would be both stupid enough, reckless enough, and dumb enough to make completely and totally defamatory false statements that are easily proven false. Show the proof that I stole a video, Show the proof that I stole other videos from other people. That's what he said essentially in his filings. Show the police report that proves that you called the police on me.

Did you call the police on me for stealing a video? Like putting a video on YouTube? You've called the police over that. Really, I'd love to see the police report.

And if he can't produce it, then he made knowingly made false statements to YouTube. And he can try to squirm out of it or worm out of it, but it is what it is. I will say that you know all of these legal problems that we get, which are really childish and stupid, like you're gonna threaten me with legal shit because we proved you were lying, scumbag, you know, But this is this is what happens. There's a theory that the church impersonated again None called Sister Lucia for approximately fifty years.

The evidence is pretty credible. I have seen that. That is quite the rabbit hole. Right, And Arlene says Old Rock is the best yeah back before digital right and Charlie trolchol with one for the goal.

Thank you for your kindness, general city and support, he says for the Legal Defense Fund, Well, it's going to be interesting to see kind of what happens with the whole situation. And I have never Oh we have Gotson Gotsen Hammer gifted a sub So thank you for your kindness, generosity, gots and Hammer. I hope I'm saying that right, go six t Z six h Hammer six are got sticks. I think it's got stick sex and Hammer.

Maybe you can tell me how to say that. But I thank you for your kindness, generosity and support of the show. It is much much appreciated. Tampa.

Blood Magic is over there and plouding in the kicklive chat. Good to see him as well, and we have broken hip. Has been a member for two months, so thank you for that, and thanks to all of our members. People have asked me how to I become a member.

You just small the join button and for a few dollars a month, you get member badge, letting everybody in the live chat know you're a big show supporter, and you get access to our members the only section with many many extra videos, so you get a bunch of extra goodies as well, and we thank you all for that. And failing that, you can join on Patreon for a dollar a month. You get the same benefits, but you don't get the extra YouTube goodies. So yeah, I'm glad that we started.

This is just the start of trying to tackle this subject. And let me know in the live chat. Put a one if you want to see me interview some experts on the shroud of touring and have some guests that are experts or researchers into the shroud of touring, and too if you don't care to see experts, if you don't want me to do interviews with the experts, it's on this particular subject. And if you have any suggestions for future shows, please put them in all capital letters, and we consider all those things.

I have a huge list of shows that people ask me, subjects that people ask me to do shows on Would you want too if you want Wilcock as a guest, I don't think I would want him, but I am seeing a lot of ones, so we'll see if we can't reach out. There's a many people that I suppose you could say are kind of on the podcast circuit that are experts in the shroud of touring or have done many, many years of research. And if you're interested, there is one website and he's first on my list. There's a gentleman.

It's called Shroud Research shr oudresearch dot net, and there is an interesting gentleman there named Bob Rucker. And Bob Rucker has a Bachelor of Science and a master's degree in nuclear engineer from the University of Michigan and professional engineering certificates in nuclear engineering and mechanical engineering. He worked for thirty eight years in the nuclear industry performing nuclear analysis computer calculations for the design of advanced nuclear reactors. He's one of the big researchers and maybe one of the people who are claiming that it is some form of radiation which created the image on the shroud.

I listened to several of his interviews, and he's got some interesting science to back up his belief that the shroud is indeed the genuine burial cloth of Christ. Father Andrew Dalton. Sure, Father Malachi Martin, Oh, if only I could. That guy's interesting his books.

I really liked Malackie Martin's books and his interviews on art bell. Anybody remember those. That's blast from the past. Father Malachi Martin for those that aware.

He was a Catholic priest and also an exorcist. And they made some Hollywood movies and Russell Crowe played him in the latest Hollywood retelling of his story, which was not good. I think they went a little too Hollywood on that one, right, They got a drama it up, but holy he like they have him shooting a pig in this because he convinced the demon to jump from a human host to the pig and then he shot the pig in the head. It's a whole I didn't like that movie.

I think that movie is called The Pope's Exorcist. But it is true that Malickie Martin was a Catholic priest and exorcist, and he was the exorcist for Rome for quite some time. All right, So I believe, my friends, that we have done our due diligence. I believe I will be back on Thursday night at seven pm Eastern time.

But I have to say there's some good news, and that is I'm off another one of these terrible meds that make me drowsy and tired and lethargic, and I'm feeling a lot better, so we may go back to our usual schedule. I'm trying to keep things light for those I'm aware. You know, I just had a big medical thing happen and I'm slowly feeling like myself again and recovering. And our current schedule is Tuesday, Tuesdays and Thursdays and sometimes a weekend show.

And if you get a chance, we did a Kick exclusive show just on Sunday, So go over to our kickchannel. It's Kick dot com Truth Seeker show you'll find us and there is Urban Terror with one for the goal saying great show and subject tonight you didn't have to raise your blood pressure. That's another part of this equation. It used to be believe it or not.

Way back when this show started, Urban Terror, what we would do is we would have like a week's worth of shows that were like tonight's show, kind of like calm and scholarly, a lot of research and a lot to ponder, you know, and a lot of discussion or interviews that were kind of more on the calm side, and then maybe once every couple of weeks there'd be a big blowout show where I'd be yelling and screaming at scumbags and grifthers, and for whatever reason, well I kind of know the reason. Those shows get more attention and get more views. So I kind of got passively encouraged to be a maniac more.

But I'm going to try to get back to, you know, being calm, and you know, I don't know, I don't want to screw up my zen or my health with like I'm supposed to avoid things that raise my blood pressure right now for obvious reasons, and I think a good way to do it is to have some of these more calm shows. But you're right, Urban Terror, thanks for noticing, and we have is yale is yaleo of stuff is a why a lot of stuff. I think that is glad you're doing better. Thanks for the show.

Well, thank you for kindness, generosity and support. Much much appreciated, and we have M three ga princesses. Great show and very good to hear your recovering. I'm feeling so much better this week than I did in the previous weeks.

I guess all that rest helps. I really am trying to take it easy and not do much. Against my better judgment. I started binge watching Stranger Things, which I completely missed.

You know, but I'm one of those late adopters, like I didn't do Game of Thrones until it was years old. I didn't do Breaking Bad until it was years old, or Sopranos until it was years old. Von Schrgan with one for the goal says, oh my god, the goal. Well, yes, the goal is going to end here, but we got more than halfway there and that's sometimes that's good enough.

And Freddy the Cat, thank you for the show. Thank you Von Schrgen for being a member of your kindness, generosity and support. And thank you Freddie the Cat for your kindness, generosity and support. And Arlene is reminding everybody that the kick only streams how to get to them but if you're a YouTube channel member or a Patreon supporter, I do upload those.

I upload all of the kick only shows so you can catch the replay in the member section or on Patreon as well. Otherwise you've got to go over to kick before they I think they only keep the streams for two weeks at my level, and then the shows are deleted and newer shows will be there. In other words, they don't archive every show like YouTube does. But thank you our lean for your kindness and moderation, best moderator in the game, and thank you for your kindness, generosity and sup for all of you supporters.

So we have done our due diligence. Like I said, I should be back on Thursday, but if I'm feeling like I am today, I might get another show off of my I've got a lot of things on my to do list, and tonight was one of them. So thank you for coming here and spending some time with me to explore what I believe is an enduring mystery. My mind is still not made up.

There's some things about this whole thing that just scream something's weird here, right, Like the pollen on the cloth that comes from plants, that is only in Jerusalem's that's a weird one, you know. And there's a great deal of blood evidence, but it's a little data heavy. The science on the blood that was found, and by the way, it is verifiably real human blood is another head scratcher because there's apparently there's blood that was pre mortem blood, there's blood that was post mortem blood, meaning that the body was bleeding while it was alive, and then you know, there was blood that oozed out after the death event. And both types of blood, both pre mortem and post mortem, have been verifiably found on the on the shround.

And if we if we are to believe the skeptics that this is just a hoax, well that's some great lengths to go to get the pollen from plants from Jerusalem. Make sure that the image can be seen like a photograph once it's once you do a photo negative of it, put blood on it from a living person and a dead person. It's it's it's an enduring mystery. That's why we're here because I'm going to continue to look into this enduring mystery.

And there's been a resurgence of interest in the Shroud of touring in the recent years and you'll see that on YouTube. If you just put Shroud of Touring in the search box, you'll see there's lots of Tucker Carlson did a show on this, Piers Morgan. It's becoming a very popularized subject again, so I wanted to dive back into it. You know, the three D information being embedded on this leads me to believe, like, how does a hoaxer know how to do all of this before in the thirteen hundreds.

I would really love to conduct some of my own experiments to see if we can form an image something like the shroud. And I happen to have a life size bust of Jesus kind of digging out. I think it's somewhere in a box, since you know, you ever move and you just never unpacked. It's just, you know, it's boxes in my garage that were put there the day we moved in, you know.

But it would be interesting to see if we can recreate something like the shroud of Touring. And if you guys would like to see that, I'll certainly give it a try. There's various ways that people have tried to reproduce the image, usually with some sort of mask or a sculpture and they pigment the sculpture and then they lay the shroud over it and press, and that creates an imprinted image. Perhaps it's definitely, it's definitely interesting.

And of course being raised Catholic, these kind of things that have always fascinated me, and as a child who was trying to be a good Christian and really wanted to believe that, you know, my religion was true and real, and you know, I would look to these things like relics or like the shroud of tour and as proof that the Bible wasn't just stories, that the Bible was more than that. Right, the crowd was Jacques's demo lay and not Jesus. Stephen the Cambian, Okay, you say so, So we've done our due diligence. I am going to bounce on out of here.

Please follow me on Twitter at Stephen Cambian. If you're listening in audio podcast Lane, we love and appreciate you. But please do go on over to Twitter. Put truth sickers one word in the search bar.

You'll see a strange guy with sunglasses pop up. That would be me. Go to the channel, smash the subscribe button, hit the Notification belt really really does help. And we love and appreciate you guys in audio podcast LAMB, but you're missing the live and interactive tapings and we love that so we welcome you to be a part of it.

So and also if anybody has ideas or suggestions for shows you can and show topics, you can email me at True Secret Show at gmail dot com. So that's all I got for your friends. I hope that this I guess first dive into this enduring mystery was interesting to you. Thanks for coming here and spending some time with me.

No place I would rather be. But that's all I got for your friends. So until next time, my name is Stephen Cambian. Good night, and God bless all of you.

Attempt intimating active intent, buildings and intents, building intended to. Attemt un. Speaking and people coming up a completed span, people past

Comments & Upvotes

Transcript

The greetings and salutations friends, and welcome back. We are here tonight to do a few things. Many people throughout the history of our show have asked me to do a show on tonight's subject, which is the Shroud of Turin. But I have very effectively evaded doing a show on this particular subject, and there's a few reasons for that.

First, I was raised Catholic Christian, specifically Catholic, so I'm sure that I have my biases about a lot of this, but those biases may be not what you think. Because I was a very inquisitive young man, and I suppose anybody who knows me knows that I'm very skeptical of paranormal claims and probably always have been. And it didn't matter to me whether it was the gypsy fortune teller saying she could talk to your dead grandmother in our neighborhood, or the Catholic priest that said mass every Sunday, when people claimed miraculous or paranormal supernatural things, I was always very skeptical, and so the Shroud of Tourin has been one of those mysteries, however, an enduring mystery which I can't ever quite make my mind upon. So you know, when people ask me what is my opinion on the shroud, it's in my gray basket, and perhaps it always will be until further scientific studies are done.

So we're going to be going over a great deal. I have so much to share with you. And the other thing we are doing is going back to trying to cover more subjects than personalities or people, because we can see the trouble the covering people can bring, like legal troubles or lawsuit threats or you know, I don't think the Catholic Church or anybody is going to threaten to assume me for expressing my opinions on this subject tonight. Maybe it's a bit safer, Maybe it's a bit you know, less stress.

I don't have to worry about this one or anybody. Well, of course, people are so easily offended, you know, I could say anything. So we'll take a moment to welcome in and recognize the live chat we've got. Sherry is in the live chat.

Tim Curley is here, our wonderful moderator, Arlene and I saw spooky earlier operations shut down. Blazing Mad Trollie troll Troll is here. Jonathan Matten is here, Garagie is here, diaper Fur holding down the kick live chat von Srgen Pig Monster two twenty reel is here one moment here and if I miss you, I apologize. The outer planet is here.

Shout out to the outer planet. Patty Wilhelm is here. Ray Gunner is here holding down the kick chat as well. Sherry is saying she was brought up in the Roman Catholic Church.

Well, we're going to get into this. So when I was younger, I first heard about the shroud of Turin, which purports to be, or alleges some alleged to be the actual burial shroud or cloth of Jesus Christ. And you know, there is historical proof that a man named Jesus in that time general date and region existed and was crucified by the Romans. Some people say otherwise, you know, people will say what they're going to say.

You know, the the Jewish priests handed over Jesus to punsiou his pilot, the you know, I supposed Roman authority in the region who made the actual decision, famously washing his hands of the decision to crucify Jesus Christ. So this this actual it's a linen cloth, and it has a faint image of what appears to be what appears to be naked man with wounds consistent with Roman crucifixion at the time of Jesus. And I'm gonna go on scripts now if nobody minds, because I like to get the facts and the figures correct, and there is so much on this. But before I do that, I'm going to share my screen the best pictures that i've you know, kind of looked all over the internet and I found a few places that have some really good, high quality imagery of the shroud of Turin, And here we can see the image is of the front of a human body that is crossing its arms over the groin area.

There is a tremendous amount of you know, people pointing out things like there are wounds around the head that people say would be consistent with someone being tortured or forced to wear around a crown of thorns. There is a gash or wound on the side of the check, which is consistent with Jesus and the biblical story that he was speared they wanted to make sure he was dead. Their holes through the wrists and feet also consistent with Roman crucifixion practices at the time, although there was many it should be noted, and this is probably a very little known fact, but there were an incredible variation in crucifixion. In crucifixions, for example, some were crucified on an X cross, some on a T cross, some on a capital T cross, and sometimes the people would be tied to the cross, sometimes they would be nailed to the cross.

But what's very interesting about the Shraveturin to me is that it appears that this man depicted in the image was scourged and attacked with Roman whips that are consistent with Roman whips at the time. The wounds that are displayed on the image, i should say, are consistent with scourging weaponry that would be used to scourge a victim in those times. So there is just an incredible amount of things that lead many to believe that this is actually depicting the body of Jesus Christ. But what's incredible to me is that an incredible amount of different scientists, all different disciplines have studied the shroud, and not one of them can tell you with certainty how the image got onto the shroud.

Now there are two different camps I suppose a skeptical camp and the believer camp, or you know, and but both are kind of puzzled as to how the image actually appeared. Doesn't appear that this image was painted on. The image is incredibly thin. It only penetrates the very very top layers of the linen.

But I'm going to go onto my script because i want to make sure that we get the facts and figures correct, and it's important to note. We'll also show you that there is the back image. So basically, the cloth was laid and a body apparently or allegedly was placed on it, and then it was folded over the front side of the body. So this one, the first image, is known as the ventral image or front image, and this website states it is usually viewed horizontally during an exhibition, but the image has been positioned vertically for better viewing.

Large burns and scorch marks from the fire. This relic was in a fire in fifteen thirty two seemed to frame the image. Look for the blood on the arms, nail wounds in the wrist, wound on the side, and blood in the head on the head and hair. Also notice water stains from where the cloth was rolled up and kept in some kind of urn.

A water stain over the knees shows the image is not water soluble. The edges of the water stains are due to calcium deposits, and the back image is known as the dorsal image. Notice the apparent crown of thorns and scorge marks around the crisscross and back of the legs. About one point twenty of such marks can be counted.

There is blood or appears to be blood across the small the back that flowed from the side wound after the body was laid out horizontically after death at the bottom or the feet, one foot placed upon the other and nailed into position. Noticed the nail wounds and corresponding blood flow. Now now we're going to go And interestingly, this was what people were seeing in the cloth before it was first photographed. But once it was photographed first in eighteen ninety eight, that's where the story got stranger in my opinion.

So in eighteen ninety eight, the church finally allowed the shroud of tourn to be photographed for the very first time, and it was an amateur photographer which took the first image. And as the story goes, he went back to his dark room and almost dropped the photoplates, which at the time were glass, because the image in the negative was startling to him. Much more detail was shown in the negative image than would be shown to the naked eye. And this is, like I said, where the story gets strange, because either this is as people believe or suggest as the authentic burial cloth of Jesus.

And some say there was some sort of radiation event when Jesus rose from the dead which caused the image to appear in the cloth. I don't know if that's true or not, but we'll be exploring all of people's theories tonight during this deep dive. But what was interesting is when the photograph was when the when the shroud was first photographed in eighteen ninety eight, an incredible amount of detail, much more then can be seen with the naked eye, could be shown. And it's almost as if the negative is actually the positive of the image.

It appears much more like almost like a photograph. The negative appears almost like a photograph of you know, this crucified man. And as the story goes, the photographer was so shocked by what he saw it almost dropped the plates, believing that he was the first person to see the real face of Jesus in over two thousand years. So this is a just a display, like a laid out copy of what the image looks like when it is in negative form.

Now give me a moment here, because I have some more and more detail of this, of course, is the regular image or positive image, and people have noticed and said that the face looks just like the Jesus that we all know. But it's important to note that I don't believe that there was any like painted depictions of Jesus for hundreds of years after his death. So do we really know that Jesus was, you know, brown haired, bearded? I don't know, but it is interesting what this face appears to be to a Christian that's the face of Jesus, or it appears very strongly that it could be the face of Jesus.

And there's another depiction. So this is a full body of the negative image, which again it shows an incredible amount more detail than you can see with the naked eye. And it's interesting that people were excited about the shroud before the picture, but after the picture is when it really rose to worldwide prominence as an alleged relic of the burial shroud of the biblical Jesus. So let me get back to my script, though, Oh before I do that, let's take a moment to thank some kind and generous benefactors.

We've got Noka forty eight n says Loha friends. I'm here, but I will be driving. I will look forward to the show. I love history.

Thank you Stephen for awesome, awesome work. Well, thank you Noka for your kindness, generosity and support. And with regrets, I apologize, but I'm not going to be playing a lot of stripper bumpers tonight. Just I don't want to talk about Jesus and play stripper bumpers.

To thank people for the super chats tonight, I hope you understand. And Tim Curley is here with one for the goal as well. Thanks Stephen, great topic and I appreciate your deep dive and research. Here another great show as always.

Well, it just started. It might be terrible, and I've noticed we've got pretty low attendance tonight. See what happens when I go off the script, even if I or our usual subject matter. I guess, even when I'm doing something that so many people have asked me to do, and I want to put on the record.

You know, I was raised Catholic, and even when I was a child whether the shroud you could ask I could ask ten different priests and ten different nuns, and ten different priests and ten different nuns would all give me a different answer when I asked them if the shroud of Tourin really is the burial shroud of Jesus. Some believed it is, and some were more skeptical and claimed that it might have been a forgery. Now it's important to note that the historical, you know, chain of custody is very important. So as far as the chain of custody goes, we only know the Shroud of Tourin has been known or existed since the thirteen hundreds, leading many to believe that this is a forgery.

From the thirteen hundreds when religious reliquary or relics were a big financial draw. In other words, people kind of went nuts in Europe and would say, oh, have you been to this church? It has the nails of the crucifixion from what Jesus was crucified in their altar, and other people would have different relics of all different types and these were big tourist draws and therefore a big financial boom to the churches that housed them. So many people think that the shroud was just a created art piece, a fake designed to fool pilgrims so that they could make money off of the tourism and the pilgrims.

But back to back to my script here so that we get things correctly on the record. So the shroud of Tourin is a linen cloth bearing the faint image of a crucified man, or apparently crucified man, and this has captivated scholars, scientists, and the faithful for centuries now. It is often purported to be the actual burial shroud of Jesus Christ. It remains one of the most studied artifacts in history.

Tonight, I'm going to try my best to provide balanced scholarly presentation here and present the strongest arguments for the shroud's authenticity as a first century relic, alongside some compelling evidence suggesting it is indeed a medieval forgery. Now you may know why I can't make up my mind on this one. Key scientific analyses will be explored, including when I think is one of the most important scientific studies of the shroud, the nineteen eighty eight carbon fourteen dating. We'll be discussing that in detail.

Also. You know, I think we can't really cover this without covering the Catholic Church's official stance on the shroud's authenticity. We'll be exploring that along with its economic implications for the church and the city of Turin. Like I said, there's plenty of Taurus dollars to be had, and I believe the last time that the shroud was actually exhibited publicly.

Usually they keep it in a box, a temperature controlled box that I think is even filled with argone gas because it's inert. They're trying to preserve this thing forever. It's not just like hanging up in the church. But when they do display it, hang it up and let people come and see the actual shroud, they draw millions and millions of people.

Now, I will say, to their credit, the Catholic Church doesn't like sell tickets to these events, but you know, if somebody goes there, they're gonna draw. They passed the collection played around, Let's leave it at that. They certainly passed the collection played around to those two million people. So we're gonna really dig deep into some historical records Tonight, some scientific studies, and more modern scientific studies and analyzes.

But really, you know, I titled Tonight's broadcast, uh, you know, enduring mysteries, because this one is one of those. It's just an enigma to me. I really think there needs to be a lot more research into the shroud from a scientific perspective. The problem is that the Catholic Church is the gatekeepers, So just just some more facts and figures.

Is actually a rectangular linen cloth measuring approximately four point four meters by one point one meters, and it features a faint straw. It features faint straw yellow images of the front and back of a naked man with his hands folded over his groin. The figure appears to be bearded with shoulder length hair and wounds that many say are consistent with biblical descriptions of Jesus' crucifixion, including marks on the wrists, feet, side, and forehead. There are reddish brown stains on the cloth that were originally interpreted as blood.

Later I believe later scientific evidence proved that those stains were blood aligned with these crucifixion injuries. The cloth is woven in a three to one herringbone twill pattern from flax fibers and is consistent with burial shrouds consistent with that time period and geographical location. The shrouds showed signs of historical damage, including burn marks from the fifteen thirty two fire, and this was repaired with patches. It is housed in Touring, Italy at Saint John the Baptist Cathedral since fifteen seventy eight.

It has been there. But the shrouds origins really are, especially from a historical perspective, are shrouded in mystery. The documented history of this particular shroud, which, by the way, I just want to make sure we understand that many people try to say that some other historical or effects were actually this rout of touring, but they called it something different, or they thought it was something different. You know, people are trying to fill in the blanks.

I suppose you could say from zero to thirteen th fifty four with other sightings. For example, there was a painting several hundred years before thirteen fifty four that depicted something that looked like the shroud of Tour and people say, well, there's the proof that it existed before thirteen fifty four. It's a bit of a quagmire looking into the history. But the documented history or chain of custody begins in thirteen fifty four in ly Re, France, where it was exhibited by the Knight Jeffrey de Charnay.

Prior to this, there are really no reliable records about the Shroud, although some proponents suggest connections to earlier relics like the Image of Odessa and the Shroud. Since it surface has passed through various owners, including the House of Savoy, before being donated to the Holy See or Catholic Church in nineteen eighty three. Public exhibitions of the actual shroud are very rare, with notable viewings in twenty ten with over two million visitors and twenty fifteen, and there was another planned exhibition for twenty twenty five, but I believe that that has been canceled. The shroud's image which was first revealed to be a photographic negative in eighteen ninety eight by Secundo Pia.

He was the photographer who took the first picture. And by the way, when Secundo Pia took this first picture, everybody said that he faked the picture, that it was some sort of crazy hoax for publicity, but when it was next allowed to be photographed, people found the same result. This incredible image appeared in the negative. The shroud exhibits unique properties that have fueled debates over its authenticity.

Some view the out of touring as some sort of miraculous imprint from Christ's resurrection, like a byproduct of that event. Others see it merely as a cleverl medieval artwork. But tonight we're, like I said, we're going to try to balance these perspectives. I'll be giving you the arguments for authenticity that proponents of the shroud use, and also I'll be giving you a perspective of some of the more skeptical people who have studied this artifact.

So proponents of the Shroud's authenticity argue that it is indeed and could be a lot of people use some strange phrasing too, like it couldn't be anything else other than this the burial cloth of Jesus. And it's interesting to note that much like in the UFO community or in the ghost hunter community, there exists sort of talking points which get repeated ad nauseum, often without proof. So we have to be very careful when we examine the things that people are claiming or saying. But as far as it being an authentic relic from the first century, there are several lines of evidence that support this claim, like the image formation and its properties.

The image is superficial, penetrating only the top two hundred to six hundred nanometers of the fibers, and the shroud has been found to be without pigments, binders, paint, or anything like that. Of course, people still argue this issue, but there is some science to support that there is none of those things. There's no pigments, paint, or you know, medium that could have been used to create you know, I have been studying high resolution images and to me a lot of especially not the negative image, but when you look at it with the naked eye, it really looks to me like it was almost burned into the cloth, not painted into the cloth. So interesting that we also found out that the image in the shroud actually encodes three dimensional information, and this was demonstrated by image analyzer studies in the nineteen seventies, which suggested that the image may have been formed by contact with a three dimensional object, possibly a body.

Years after the nineteen seventies image analyzer studies first noticed that there's actual three D data and information that is embedded into the image. I get when people say, oh, it's a fake, I don't understand even if it's a fake from the thirteen hundred's how somebody knew how to encode three D image information in a two D image. That's another mystery about this whole thing. So forensic pathologists have looked at the shroud and confirmed the anatomical accuracy of wounds that are consistent with Roman crucifixion of the first century, including nail marks in the wrist and over one hundred and twenty scourge marks from a flagrum.

That's what the Romans used to beat or whip prisoners and victims with. It's called a flagrum, and the injuries shown in the shroud are consistent with a Roman flagrum injury that you'd get from, you know, being scourged in the first century by the Romans. And this is very interesting because when people argue that this is a clever forgery or a clever hoax, I just think to myself, there must have been an incredible hoaxer because he was able to track down what a wound from a flagrom in the first century looks like and reproduce it exactly. There is also some biological and chemical evidence the reddish stains on this shroud contain iron oxide and proteins that are consistent with human blood, including Billie Ruben levels that are indicative of trauma.

So this again is consistent with somebody who has been crucified. And one of the most intriguing aspects that people point to as proof that the shroud is authentic is there's actually pollen grains from plants on the shroud of Turin. This has been scientifically proven, and those pollen grains are plants that are native only to the Jerusalem area. And this is perplexing because again, if we imagine that there's someone in the thirteenth century that's trying to create a hoax burial cloth of Jesus, what they go so far as to figure out exactly what a flagoran wound looks like and reproduce it, And then, you know, I don't understand, do they go to Jerusalem and shake pollen off of plants there and put it on the shroud?

Because there is verifiably pollen from plants that are native only to the Jerusalem area, which would be where Jesus lived, you know, was crucified and allegedly buried before many believe that he rose from the dead. There was also a DNA analysis of some of what people believe is blood from the cloth, and this revealed human mitochondrial DNA from diverse ethnic routs compatible with ancient people living in the Near East in the first century. There was a twenty twenty two wide angle X ray scattering study that analyzed linen degregation and dated the shrial to be somewhere between fifty five and seventy four CE, attributing discrepancies with prior dating to environmental contamination. So proponents argue that the image could result from a burst of radiation during resurrection, and this is just a hypothesis.

There's no proof for it, but this is what many people have said. But that hypothesis is supported by some scientific findings that ruled out conventional artistic methods like painting or trying to burn the image into the cloth. These arguments for the shroud's authenticity or tray the shroud as a relic that defies medieval technology. In fact, many of the proponents of its authenticity claim that no one in the thirteen hundred time period could do this.

I beg to differ and we'll see some proof about that. Okay, now on the skeptical side, let me just check them with the live chat before we continue here. Trolly troll, troll this year with one for the goal. Not that I'm complaining or anything, but I seem to recall you did a show about the shroud once before.

Nope, never have, never have. You're confusing it with we did do some shows that I called Christian mysteries, but we've never done a show. I'm thinking myself, you know, I did just have brain surgery. But no, I'm certain TROLLI troul troll, we did not do a show about the shrout of tour and yet but thank you Troy trot Troeper kindness, generosity and support.

Will take a moment to check in with the with the live chat as well. Well. This is a good question. Why would light from radiation have a beard shape?

Yeah? I mean what I have found about this Shroud of Tour in my studies of you know, and I've really really dug deep here to see both sides of the arguments, is you get more questions than answers. Like I said, when I was a child, I would ask different priests if the shroud was real, and some of them believed absolutely, Stephen, that's from when Jesus resurrected, he left a sign of his resurrection in the cloth. And others would say, no, somebody made it just to make money.

You know, believe it or not. Some priests are cynical and skeptical. That's funny that you should mention that we're chief Reviews. We're going to be getting into some of the other relic claims.

And this is why I'm very skeptical of the Catholic Church. And I will explain why. It's something I like to call the incorruptible bodies scam that the Catholic Church runs. But let me get back to the skeptical side of the arguments one moment here.

Okay, So on the skeptical side of the arguments, one second burst of radiation. That's interesting, Okay, So on the skeptical side of things, the shroud's first appearance aligns with the medieval relic trade. In thirteen eighty nine, Bishop Pierre, the our Sease of Troy's denounced the shroud tour in as a complete and total forgery, claiming that an artist confessed to quote painting it. There is no pre thirteen fifty documentation about the shroud, and a twenty twenty five study from a newly discovered document from philosopher Nicole or Ism reinforces that the shroud has medieval origins, and it's important to note that the medieval relic trade was big business.

Like I said, people would each church would have some form of relic. We've got the blood of Jesus in this cross, or we've got you know, the bones of Peter. They all would claim that they had. For example, some churches claimed that they had a relic that was a piece of wood from the cross that Jesus was crucified on.

But if you were to take all of those relics and put them together, you would see that there's enough to make ten crosses out of. So the relic trade is often fraudulent. Many say, I believe that there are many Catholic relics that are completely and totally fake, And to this day though, they make each of the churches where the relics reside tons of money. So I think a lot of me thinks that the Catholic Church doesn't want to spoil the party when it comes to relics.

So there have been some scientific replications and analyzes, including that One of the talking points you'll hear is that nobody can do this, we can't reproduce this, and that's really not the case. Several people have reproduced very very similar imagery on a linen cloth through various means, and apparently the image or one very very much like it can be replicated using techniques that were available in medieval times, such as base relief, rubbing with pigments or acid pigmentation. Walter mccrone's nineteen seventy eight analysis detected red okra and vermilion pigments in a gelatin medium, suggesting painting. So it wasn't exactly paint, but it was red okra and vermilion pigments in gelatine, a gelatin medium.

So this is where things get kind of squirrely, because you have the believer saying we've scientifically confirmed there's no paint. But then in nineteen seventy eight they detected red oakri and vermilion pigments and a gelatin medium on the shroud. Isn't that pain I think that's pain. It's something just like pain.

I don't know. And then, of course, many of the skeptical experts have pointed to anatomical inconsistencies like disproportionate limbs and unnatural blood flows which indicate artistic creation or artistic license and not a natural process being shown here. Some of the blood flow analysis has been interesting, so it appears that the blood flow shown on the trout is not what would anatomically happen if it was a natural process, which means somebody took some artistic license, you know, and drama made it more dramatic. A twenty twenty five three D analysis was just done suggested that the image actually derives from sculpture, sculpture or base relief.

In other words, someone took a sculpture of a body that you kind of can see in the image, and then they put the shroud around it, first pigmenting somehow the sculpture. Then the cloth is placed around it, and the cloth gets an imprint from the sculpture. And there's a lot of experts that are really positive that this image was created by putting it over a sculpture, not a real human body. And then of course, the most famous argument that skeptics make is the carbon fourteen dating.

In nineteen eighty eight, samples from the shroud were tested by laboratories at Oxford, Arizona, and Zurich using accelerator mass spectromity. The results dated the cloth to be aged or from twelve sixty to thirteen ninety CE with ninety five percent confidence, which actually matches its historical debut. Then when the shroud was the carbon dating dates it to around the time that the shroud first entered history. So challengers challenges include many believers challenged those carbon fourteen results.

So in other words, they carbon dated it and it was clearly from medieval times. Somewhere between the studies varied, but somewhere between twelve seventy three and thirteen ninety is what it was dated at. The challengers to this carbon dating say there were sample contamination from repairs, something like invisible reweaving with cotton, or that fire damage could have created a false a false age once carbon dated, and there is some scientific evidence for that. If the shroud was in a fire, well, there would have been a lot of smoke, and what's in smoke carbon smoke that when the shroud was in the what would be normally a very straightforward test, it could have added carbon and therefore the results of the carbon fourteen analysis could be extremely flawed.

Six. But it's interesting to note that no radio carbon expert has invalidated these tests, and the medieval date get given. It's other people like religious scholars or that raise these arguments, but no actual expert in radiocarbon dating has invalidated those original tests. So skeptics emphasize the shroud's alignment with medieval history artistry and relic forgery practices.

It was very common that people would fake relics in order to make money at the exact time that this so called relic entered history, So skeptics argue that authenticity of this actually being the burial cloth of Jesus is very unlikely without additional testing, which would overturn the original carbon dating. It's interesting that the Catholic Church, who could clear all this up by just letting new tests take place, I don't know why they don't do that. Their stance on authenticity remains in neutral position. The Catholic Church neither in dorses that it's actually the real burial cloth of Jesus, but they don't reject that either.

Pope Francis in twenty thirteen says it permits veneration as an object of devotion, viewing it as an icon of a man scourged and crucified. But Pope's Pope John Paul the second and Benedict the sixteenth encouraged scientific study without any actual doctrinal commitment. In other words, they don't want to commit that yes, this is the burial cloth of Jesus until more scientists study the cloth. The church Catholic Church apparently in trusts authenticating the shroud to be truly a first century relic and therefore quite possibly or probably or the burial cloth of Jesus to science and the Catholic Church for as long as I can remember, remember I was raised Catholic.

I mentioned that some priests would tell me it was real, and some priests would tell me it was fake. But there was also people that I would consider fence sitters, and they would say this is still no matter what it is, it's a valuable object because it has a great inspirational value two people and is the source of faith for many. Now it's important that we talk about the economic impact of the Catholic Church in Turin, because this is where you know, I'm very fond of the saying follow the money. They they the church in which this sorry, the church, the church in which the shroud is kept, has made millions and millions and millions of dollars in donations when people come to visit.

So I think there may be some economic factors when we think about this so called relic or holy relic. So of course the shroud significantly boosts tourism and economic activity, particularly during exhibitions, though the Catholic Church does not directly profit from ticket sales, as viewings are free. But of course, like I said, they're going to pass the collection plate around, and if two million people visit, even if everybody only gives them a dollar in the collection plate, that's a couple million dollars. And this of course stimulates tour in tourings, economic activity, and tourism through hotel bookings, dining related spending, and hotels are always sold out in that whole area when they exhibit this relic.

Of course, this provides an unusual bit of economic stimulus to that region. So historically relics like the shroud generate revenue through pilgrimages, donations, and of course local commerce enriching churches and the religions running those churches. For Turin. The twenty twenty five exhibition that was planned was projected to drive significant growth, contributing to Italy's tourism sector and generate millions of dollars during that event, which, by the way, I believe is canceled.

They're not going to exhibit it in twenty twenty five. I try to look into why, and I'm not quite sure why. And there are some new initiatives like a five million dollars Shroud Museum in California, which opened in twenty twenty five, and that kind of highlights its ongoing economic draw beyond tourin. And it's also interesting to note that besides the Catholic Church, they're not the only people that are cashing in on this thing, because where did it go?

There we go. These images are actually taken from a replica that you could buy on Amazon. That's right, for one hundred and sixty nine dollars, you can have a life size replica of the Shroud of tourin either the positive image or the negative image, whatever you prefer. One moment here.

I'll take a moment to catch up with the live chat. Joseph is here with one for the goal, saying sorry about the surgery. Bro side notes saw the old DSP and T interrogation, I mean interview awesome. As for the shroud, there's so much debate, but I believe.

Well, there you go, Thank you, Joseph. I'm still on the fence. I'm still trying to make up my mind, but maybe I can if I go through enough of the evidence. The Outer Planet is here with one from the goal.

I hope you mentioned the face cloth, the Pseudarium of Ovido. Yeah, I am going to because okay, I'll do it right now. Actually, the outer planet, so there is another cloth as closely tied or associated with the with the shroud of Turin. It's called the Sudarium of Ovito.

But it is I don't want to say more, I don't want to say less exciting. That's probably the proper term for it. Though. It just looks like blood splotches on an old cloth that's, you know, much smaller than the shroud.

You know, it's it's a few feet by a few feet, and that relic does trace back to I think the fifth century BC. They have a chain of custody for it from the fifth century BC forward. And it's interesting people say that the Sudarium of Ovito was placed over Christ's face and then removed and sopped up a lot of blood, and then the shroud was then placed over the body. And interestingly, many people believe that when you line up the Sudarium of Ovido over the head image on the shroud of Turin, that the blood and wounds match up.

I'm not sure what I believe about that, but it is interesting that when you get into the blood analysis, it's the same blood or blood type. They haven't DNA matched it to each other, but it's the same blood type on both the Shroud of Turin and on this other face cloth, this other relic, the Sudarium of Ovito, And that to me is very very interesting. So thank you the outer planet and all of our kind and generous benefactors. We'll catch up with the live chat.

Yeah, tampon blood magic. I want DNA tests on the cloth where they found that there is DNA in the blood and the blood. The blood evidence get very interesting as well, because there appears to be pre mortem blood on the cloth and post mortem blood or I'm sorry, post mortem blood on the cloth and pre mortem blood. So in other words, that means that there was blood from a living person.

Somebody was alive when the blood from that person was deposited on the cloth, and there is then blood from someone who is deceased that is also shown on the cloth. I don't know how these Einstein's figure that out, but they did an orthodoxy. It's called the icon made without human hands. That's interesting.

Yeah, so one moment, let me get back to my notes here. So just to wrap up this section, and we have a few more sections to share with you. The rout of Torn to Me embodies a profound intersection of faith, science, and history. Arguments for its authenticity highlight its inexplainable image and potential ancient origins, bolstered by some recent scientific studies.

Conversely, Carbon fourteen dating and historical evidence strongly support that this is indeed a medieval forgery, with controversies surrounding it. The Catholic Church's agnostic stance about the shroud allows for interpretation and personal devotion without dogmatic assertion, whilst exhibitions yield substantial economic benefits for touring and the church housing the shroud to tourism and donations. I truly believe that there needs to be a great deal more of future research, perhaps involving non destructive redating, and that may resolve some of the lingering debates. And also I believe that the Catholic Church should allow new carbon fourteen dating, and this time it should be performed by maybe six separate universities or experts in these matters, and there should be no doubt when the second testing is done.

People have been trying to poke holes, I believe, into the first carbon fourteen dating since nineteen eighty eight. And I remember when that carbon fourteen dating came out in nineteen eighty eight. It was in I believe, there was a story in a Time magazine, and my father was big, big into you know, we got Popular Science, Time Magazine, Popular Mechanics, and a few others. And I remember when the carbon fourteen dating in nineteen eighty eight came out, I felt like I finally had an answer, Oh okay, it's a fake.

But recent recent, I suppose recent reignited interest in some doing more science on this strange thing called the Shroud of Turin has kind of reignited many people's curiosity, including my own. You know, maybe the carbon fourteen was off. People have suggested that they took a piece of one of the patches. I think this is very easy to clear up.

And what's frustrating about all this debate about the carbon dating is that the Catholic Church could give out, you know, like a one inch single strand of thread from this relic, and then we could clear up all of the all the confusion and all of the arguments and doubt about the original dating. So there really does need to be an incredible amount more research. But it's interesting to me, just interesting to me, just how many scientists are taking the scientific study of this relic or artifact incredibly seriously. So there's a great deal of research on the bloodstains, and I have some more on the pollen.

But before we get to that one moment here, before we get to that, we'll catch up with the live chat. Have China clone the blood sample, you know, if they could get that, that's where this gets even it gets kind of strange as a story. I've often thought that what if they could get They apparently did get mitochondrial DNA from what appears to be blood on the shroud, and what if that really is the blood of Jesus and they clone them and then that's the Antichrist. Right, interesting idea, at least for a movie.

Right. So we're going to talk for a moment about why I don't trust the Catholic Church when they claim they have something paranormal or miraculous. And I've got a great personal story to share with you about that one moment here. Okay, So there's a big reason that I don't trust the Catholic Church when it comes to what they tell me about miraculous things or supernatural things.

This is the body of Saint John Newman. It is in the cathedral of Saint John Newman in Center City, Philadelphia. Anybody remembers stand By Me? You remember that movie stand by Me?

Hey want to go see a dead body? So we had during our religious classes, we had a class and one of the classes was all about Saint John Newman. Saint John Newman, that is his purported to be his body in the bottom of this altar in his cathedral in Center City Philadelphia. He had something that people call, or Catholics would call, an incorruptible body.

And so essentially one of the proofs that a saint is in heaven or is a saint. Before someone is canonized as a saint, they exhume the body. They exhume the body, and there's strange because there's all different criteria, but apparently if the body is in a certain condition, they declare the body to be incorruptible, like it doesn't rot. It's perfectly preserved, not mummified, but perfectly preserved.

And what you will find if you dig into this very morbid. First of all, I think it's morbid to put a dead body on display in a church. But you know, when I was a child, I was like, wait, so this guy's body is in the church in a glass box and you could just go look at it. And the priest teaching me Clas, said, yeah, anybody can go and see it.

And I was like, is that his real body? Father, And yeah, that's his real body. And I at that point, I was very young. I don't think I'd ever seen a dead body before.

So, you know, being a curious young man, I got some bus fare and I went down to the cathedral of Saint John Newman to see that this body that apparently was in perfect condition and had not decayed. And I got to tell you it was it was a pretty disappointing experience because what happened is I was altar boy, so I wasn't afraid of like walking around a Catholic church or up on the stage or on the altar. And I walked right up. I went into the cathedral and it was I don't know, mid morning, maybe ten am, and there was nobody there.

And this was on a Saturday, and the weather, as I recall, was terrible. It was like really cold and rainy, like icy rain. So there's nobody around. And I'm looking around the church and there's nobody around, and I went to the first pew, the closest that I could get without going up on the stage, and I'm looking at this thing, and I'm going, that's not a real body.

It can't be a real body. And so eventually I got up the carriage. I looked around again, and I walked right up to this thing and put my nose right in the glass, right at this guy's head, and I'm looking at it, and I'm looking looking at it, and I go, that's a mask. That's not a that's not a person's face.

And then all of a sudden I was startled because a priest had come into the church from the side door or something and startled me, young man, you're not allowed up there, and I'm like, good Catholic boy, like, oh, I'm sorry, father. I just had to see it close up. I came all the way here on the bus and everything to see Saint John Newman. And so the priest stopped to talk to me for a few minutes and I said, that's not a real face, and he said, no, it's it's it's a wax mask.

What what do you mean, it's a wax mask. It's supposed to be incorruptible. Well yeah, but you know we uh, they use a wax mask. And I'm like, well, there is the rest of them preserved.

Why do you need the mask if his face is and his body is perfectly preserved. And he explained, you know, all these different reasons for why they do that. I don't know, but I look back at it again this time sure that what I was seeing was a mask. So it turns out, if you really dig into this and this is a morbid subject, they basically just build a wax dummy around this person's skeleton, and then they tell everybody that the body does not rot, it's incorruptible, which the term incorruptible is kind of a kind of a stupid it's kind of a stupid thing.

One moment though, I have a video about this. So this is why I'm skeptical of any church, especially the Catholic Church, making claims. They might ask yourself, why would they do that? Fake a body?

And again, it's money. Every year people go to on pilgrimages to Saint John Newman's Cathedral. They make a lot of money. They make a lot of money, a lot a lot of money.

One moment here, I might getting tripped up here. I have a video about the incorruptible bodies, and I get it that this is kind of off the beaten path, right, But you know what, Before we do that, I want to share this video about the three D information that is encoded, and we'll put our fair Use banner up. This is a transformative work. We're educating the public.

We'll be critiquing the video that we're sharing and discussing it with our live chat. This is fair use friends. One moment here, so there's a man named Ray downing who is a three D CGI artist. And when he heard and realized that there was three D information that was embedded in the Shroud of Touring image, he became intrigued and he wondered if he could take the data from the three D information that is encoded in the shroud and create a model of the true face of the man from the cloth.

And this is where it gets interesting. And by the way, if you just Google, not Google, if you use YouTube search bar, just put in Shroud of Touring, you will find this. There was a documentary that was called The Face of the Real Face of Jesus. Now they're calling it something else, but it's on YouTube.

You could watch it for free. Very very interesting and informative. Peace on the Shroud of Touring end on this person Ray Downing. It's been shrouded in mystery for almost two thousand years.

The true face of Christ. In all of human history, no other faces as recognizable as the face of Jesus. No one knows what Jesus actually looked like. Now for the first time, modern technology science.

So here we see religion come together. I wasn't quick enough on the still the Face of Christ. So that's that is a depiction of how the shroud was placed around the body, which I think is very important so that we can see. Christ in a chapel in Turin, Italy, encased in bulletproof glass.

Is the most studied object in the world, the shroud of Turin. I don't know that that's an accurate statement. The most studied object in the world. I will say that I believe it's really like thousands of scientists has studied this thing.

So maybe this ancient cloth bears the image of a tortured and crucified man. Some believe this artifact to be the actual burial shroud of Jesus, the face of the man in the shroud. And here we see a close up image of what a here's to be. The face in the shroud was scarcely visible until us startly.

And here's the negative version of it. So that's a much better view. And isn't it incredible? Like that looks like a photograph to me, It really looks like a photograph when the negative images is shown shrouded in mystery.

Yes, all right, one moment here No one, two, three, ABC with one for the goal saying praise the cast, thank you for your kindness. And I hope you all forgive me. I don't want to be talking about Jesus and playing stripper bumpers tonight, so we'll save the strippers for another night. Try to be a serious, studious, research based show for once.

Thank you for your kindness, generosity and support. Much much appreciated. One second, so this is a close up where you can really see like it looks like a photograph. It looks like a photograph of a face.

How did a medieval artist get that image on that cloth? And how did they know that years later something called photography would be invented. And when you negative the image, you'll get the startling view of it looking like a photograph of a man. It's pretty pretty interesting to me.

The photographic negative was produced. But there is an additional inexplicable property of this image which caught the attention of three D computer graphics artist Ray Downing. Yeah, and look at that. So when they pull the image and the three D data, Ray Downing is this artist.

He has said that it's almost like there's instructions for creating a mold embedded in the image, which I think is pretty interesting. And now I just want to be sure that We're clear there wasn't a he even Ray Downey would admit there wasn't a complete data set. They were only able to extrapolate so much three D information from the image on the shroud. And then of course they have to use some artistic license.

For example, they had to figure out the eyebrows, which weren't clear in the three D data or weren't it wasn't pristine enough to know exactly the shape and with and everything, so they had to use some artistic license when creating this three D rendered face of what appears to be the man in the shroud. But still it's still pretty interesting what they were able to do from the three D information that they could get from the actual image. Encoded within the fibers of this cloth is three D information which shouldn't be there. It's as if someone using an unknown technology hit a blueprint for constructing a three dam in statue within this two dimensional image.

That's very interesting. Go back to that here see the. Internal statue within this two dimensional image. And like I said, Ray Downing has said, it was almost like they encoded instructions for making a mold of the face, a negative mold of the face in the image in two dimensional image.

Extracting and refining this encoded information to create that statue. So that's some incredible dedication. The guy spent a year of his life to see what he believed to be the. Face of Jesus, to reveal for the first time, and here is the results of that work, face of the man.

In the Shroud. This new portrait of Jesus drew worldwide attention in the news media. And yeah, this guy, this was a big worldwide story when originally this person Ray Downing, and I believe he did it with the you know, some funding from the History Channel. They of course made a documentary about.

The subject of a History Channel special inspired by quotes from the New Testament. Downing has gone on to illustrate a library of Jesus portraits based on the Shroud of Turine image, a face both hidden and Yeah. So after the initial extraction and building of it, then he went on to make like a whole gallery of artistic more. I think artistic renderings of the face from the shroud.

Field in time suffer little children and forbid them not to come unto me. Lazarus come forth. So these are artistic depictions of stories from the Bible, but using the face that was extracted from the shroud of Turin. Oh, my father, if it be possible, let this cup pass from me.

World hates you. You know that it hated me before it hated you. So he named each of the paintings or artistic works after one verse of a Bible to in the New Testament. Spirit.

Greater love hath no man than this, that a man laid down his life for his friends. I am the resurrection and the life. My kingdom is not of this world. All right, Well we get through that, and I have a few more bits to share with you for this, for this evening.

Now I have to say, there's just so much to go through that you could never do it. I'd be here for twelve hours. So we might do a part two, maybe a part three as I sift through all of the data. The deep dive will continue.

But one moment here, how did I not I didn't upload the one file to my Google drive. Let me get that right now. One second. So there's a very interesting there's a very interesting YouTube channel which is run by an actual funeral director, a mortician, and she was very interested about those incorruptible bodies, as was I one moment here.

Oh wait, let me just I don't want to not mention her incorruptible bodies. She's one of the first search results. This mortician has a couple million subscribers. She talks about morbid stuff.

Kind a gothic girl, ah and a mortician. Let me get that before we share the video. How to tell if your Saint is incorrupt is the Yeah. So her name is Caitlin Doherty the ou g h t y or doty Caitlin Doty, and she made an interesting video and this again is why I have doubts about Let's give that a few minutes here.

I want to share some of the more skeptical side of the story as well, because there's many people like I said, that use talking points like they couldn't have done this in the thirteenth century, and that that is apparently not the case at all. So and is also somebody appears to have proved that the shroud of Tourin wasn't laid on a human body, but rather a sculpture, a modeling study suggests. So we'll share that. I don't know one moment here, so some of the talking points of the true believers get kind of ripped apart as people perform experiments.

In a study published Monday July twenty eighth in a Journal of Archaio Mtry, Brazilian three D digital designer Cicero Morez, who specializes in historical facial reconstruction, used modeling software to compare how the cloth drapes over a human body versus how it drapes over a low relief sculpture of one. The image on the shroud of Tourin is more consistent with a low relief matrix. More As told Live Science in an email. Such a matrix could have been made out of wood, stone, or metal and pigmented or even heated only in the areas of contact, producing an observed pattern.

He said, So here is a sort of three D illustration of how the shroud could have been placed over a sculpture of a body to create the image somehow, And according to this digital artist, this is more consistent. The image on the shroud is more consistent with being placed over a statue or a created sculpture rather than an actual human body. So, and I suppose low relief would mean it would be kind of flatter. So a three D body would create a different sort of an image apparently than a low relief sculpture would.

I just thought that was pretty interesting part of the story. So when people say it's definitely from being placed over a human body, the jury's out even on that. And one of the other skeptical takes that I thought was incredibly important is that, you know, people have said, and like I said, it's not a fact but rather a talking point. People have said that this could not have been produced in the thirteenth century.

They just didn't have the technology to do it. And here from NBC News Italian scientists again this is fair use reproduces the shroud of Tourin. An Italian scientists said he has reproduced the shroud of Tourin, a feat that he says proves definitively that the linen some Christians revere as Jesus christ burial cloth is indeed imity fake. So on the left we have the image from the actual shroud of Turin and on the right here it's pretty close is an image that this person created.

An Italian scientist said he has reproduced the shroud of Tourin. The article states the fact that he says proves definitively that the linen some Christians revere as Jesus christ burial cloth is in fact a medieval fake the shroud, and they give the measurements. Here bears the image eerily reversed, like a photographic negative of a crucified man, which some believers say is Christ. And the scientist goes on to say, we have shown that it is possible to reproduce something like which has the same characteristics as the shroud.

Luigi Galisachio galisatio e Lee, who is due to illustrate the results at a conference on the paranormal this weekend in northern Italy. The scientists is a professor of organic chemistry at the University of Pavia. He made available to Reuter's the paper he will deliver and the accompanying comparative photographs so to get the image. Scientists have been at a loss to explain how the image was left on the cloth.

Garla Shelley reproduced the full size shroud using materials and techniques that were available in the Middle Ages. They placed a linen sheet flat over a volunteer and then rubbed it with a pigment containing traces of acid. A mask was used to create the face. The pigment was then artificially aged by heating the cloth in an oven and washing it, a process which removed it from the surface but left a fuzzy, half tone image similar to that on the shroud.

He believes the pigment on the original shroud faded naturally over the centuries. Then they added blood stains, burnholes, scorches, and water stains to achieve the final effect. Well, that's problematic because there is historical evidence that the shroud was in a fire. But okay.

The Catholic Church does not claim the shroud is authentic, nor that it is a matter of faith, but says it should be a powerful reminder of Christ's passion. Gallicel. This guy's name is something else. Garla Shelley, the scientist, expects people to contest his findings.

If they don't want to believe the carbon dating done by some of the world's best laboratories, they certainly won't believe me, he said. The accuracy of the nineteen eighty eight carbon dating tests were challenged by some hardcore believers, who said restorations of the shroud in past centuries had contaminated the result. The history of The shroud is long and controversial. After surfacing in the Middle East and France, it was bought by it Italy's former royal family, the Savoys, to their Seat and Touring in fifteen seventy eight.

In nineteen eighty three, ex King Umberto the Second bequeathed it to the late Pope John Paul. The shroud narrowly escaped destruction in nineteen ninety seven when a fire ravaged the Garne Chapel of the Touring Cathedral where it is held. The cloth was saved by a fireman who risked his life. Garla Shelley received funding for his work by an Italian association of atheists and agnostics, but said it had no effects on the result.

Money has no odor. This was done scientifically. If the church wants to find me in the future here I am. So that's interesting that he was able to produce a pretty good reproduction of something like the Shroud of Touring, and he did it with totally with things that would be available during the thirteenth century.

So just be warned that when you hear people technology to do this and things like that, you know, I don't really like people stating things as facts when there's no evidence to support those facts, and there is actually some evidence that dispute that this could be done in the thirteenth century, because here we have a pretty good reproduction of something like the Shroud of Tourin. It was done in a very low tech way, and so could the Shroud of Tourin have been created in the thirteenth century. It looks like it looks like it could have been. But I'd be interested to see if the reproduction has the same three D data embedded in the image or not.

Certainly looks pretty similar to the original Shroud of Turin image negative. Okay, so we're going to go to back to incorruptible bodies and why I don't trust most things that the Catholic Church says. So we mentioned this mortician and her channel is Caitlin Dodie the O U G H T Y and it's Kitlin c A I T L I N. I'll add a link to this video and the description of our video.

She's got an interesting channel if you're morbid like me. So this is her talking about these incorruptible incorruptible bodies. And as we watch these videos, maybe you my viewers, will understand that when somebody says this is paranormal or this is supernatural, I don't believe them. And there's reasons why, because we can catch them faking things, literally scamming the public with completely fake claims like this body doesn't decay.

Okay, I beg to differ, right, so along with my you know, I would truly love to believe that that was really the burial cloth of Jesus. But carbon dating bothers me a great deal. The fact that it arrived right when everybody was going relic crazy in the Middle Ages there, you know, in Europe, and it was such a big business, these fake relics. It makes me incredibly skeptical of the claims that people make.

And then again, just because someone is a priest doesn't mean that they are immune to I don't want to say lying, embellishing, or just believing something on faith rather than science. So let's take a look at this video and keep in mind that the church has been delaying the inevitable scientific research into the shroud, and I think they have a vested financial interest to keep it open. Well, it may be real, it may not be real. The science that determined that it was in the thirteenth century may have been flawed.

We don't know, it may have been contaminated. Results. They like to keep it open ended so that the mystery, I think, remains, and so does the money flowing into this church in Tourin, where the Shroud of Tourin is housed. But here's just a quick look into some of the claims that the Catholic Church makes that are completely totally provably bullshit.

Lelis died in sixteen fourteen at age sixty four. And look at him now, looking fabulous for a guy who just turned four hundred and sixty five. Yeah, that looks pretty good for a guy who just turned four hundred and sixty five. And again they say that this person is a saint and that his body is incorruptible, which to most Catholic means it doesn't rot, it doesn't decay, it's perfectly it stays perfectly preserved forever, which is kind of a strange thing.

And for those that are not Catholic, there are I don't know, there's got to be probably fifty, maybe last twenty five at the least different churches which have these bodies of saints somewhere in their church, and they are a site. They are a source of revenue. People come on pilgrimages to see these incorruptible bodies. But as in the case of Saint John Newman, all is not what is claimed.

Saint John Newman they claimed has an incorruptible body. It's a wax mask. But this one is one of the best examples of the bakery. In my opinion.

You're going to say that this saint is in heaven and his body's incorruptible and it doesn't decay or rot or you know, stink. I don't know, Am I right? He's incorrupt, as fresh as the day he died, thanks Catholicism. Wait, I don't mean to be a negative fancy here, but he doesn't really look miraculously incorrupt.

And by the way, I just want to mention that we are sharing this video to educate the public. This is a transformative work. We're educating the public, and we're going to thank Dame seven two four four for a two dollars super chat. How much of the three D rendering is artistic license?

Well, you can watch the full documentary. From what I remember, they took an artistic license with eyebrows and eyelashes that I'm aware of. But I think much of what we see in the completed image is basically the data and you know, information that was embedded in the cloth image itself. So if that's all they did was figure out the eyebrows and the eyelashes, and the rest is more or less accurate to the image on the cloth, I think they did an excellent job.

But thank you Dave seventy two four four for her kindness, generosity and support. Let's continue here. He kind of just looks like a guy made out of wax. If only I knew an incorrupt corpse expert, Oh I do.

This girl's got an incorruptible corpse expert as a friend. That's pretty interesting. And she's a mortician. National relic hunter.

Welcome. Hi. So Saint Camillis, like, what's. Up with him?

Well, when I saw him in Rome, the Sacristan, the guy who's in charge of all of the relics, said he was incorrupt. But then he unlatched a compartment underneath the body and Saint Camillis's full skeleton was laid out inside. So wait, so the whole body is fake and they have his body and by the way that skeleton I don't believe is normally displayed. I think they cover the skeleton and just show you the wax portion.

But I could be wrong. I have not been to Rome or this exact church. I've seen images both ways, with the skeleton not shown, and with the skeleton with the paddle removed and the skeleton underneath the wax fake body displayed. I knew it Saint Camilla's wax, dude, But that doesn't mean he's not incorrupt.

You can't judge a Catholic corpse by its cover. Okay, so help us understand what is the concise definition of an incorrupt corpse? And that's the problem. There really isn't a definitive, concise explanation of what an incorrupt corpse is.

And it really if you're Catholic, it depends on who you ask. There's no concise definition. Will then let's talk the list. How long is it?

How many are there? There's no list either? Well, then how is that even a title? Well, everyone who's even considered for sainthood has to be exhumed and examined as part of the canonization process.

Yeah, that's more bid. Like we're going to make you a saint, but first we have to dig up your body and check out how you're doing dead. So you're a. Potential saint, maybe going to be a saint.

And I exume you what am I looking for? No rot at all? Are you supposed to be life like? Our modern guidelines for what's acceptably incorrupt come from Pope Benedict the fourteenth in seventeen thirty four.

So the guidelines were set in seventeen thirty four. It surprise you, but the most important word he used to describe the incorrupt wasn't lifelike. It was flexible. So if they dig up your dead body and they're going to canonize you as a saint, if your body is flexible, that's good enough for them.

And thank you, Humboldt Honey for your kindness, generosity and support. Love these topics. Do Saint Germain next? I just may do that.

But the problem, Humboldt Honey, is that we get less. We get half the support for these kind of more serious shows and half the attendance, you know, But we'll do our best. I did have sort of a series of Christian mysteries and Saint Germaine would certainly fit into that. Thank you for your kindness, generosity, and support and for being a member.

Thanks to all of our members for supporting the broadcast. I'm finding no preservation allowed, so if you'd like to play along, I brought a game tell me more. It's called incorrupt or Nah. First, since they're not and by the way, just a warning, you know, some of these are truly like bizarre, Like there's some that you just look like a dead, rotting body.

It's weird when you go down this incorruptible Bodies rabbit hole. And by the way, if you search our archive, we've done an entire video before just on this subject, the incorruptible bodies. I just wanted to throw this in because this is why I don't trust when the Catholic Church says something is a relic. By the way, there's lots of proven, completely and totally provably fake relics.

I just wanted to throw this in to sort of display why I don't trust when when the church says something is supernatural or paranormal, not Catholic Saints. Here's some naz right off the bat let in nash Bog Bodies nah Rosalie Lombardo, the famous doll like Mommy from the competion crips nash Okay, hit me with my first body, Catherine. Yeah, like, I said, that's morbid. Why don't they bury that woman and let her rest in peace?

She's she's like being displayed in a church like a carnival Ya. Incorrupt or? Nah? Okay, I know, Saint Catharine.

I just did a video about her and there was all sorts of weird miraculous preservation stuff around her. So I'm going to say incorrupt nah. In nineteen ninety eight, Italian pathologists Issil Boucare from the University of Genoa studied this group of medieval female saints, all thought to be incorrupt. But they'd had organs removed, they were stuffed with herbs, and they had resin rubbed into their skin.

Everyone was so concerned with modesty that no one ever fully examined them. Yeah, so that's interesting. They're taking steps to preserve the skin with different oils and things. That's not a naturally non decaying body in my opinion.

In my view, if you have to do anything, I don't think that it should qualify. But the Catholic church plays pretty fast and loose with the requirements for sainthood and for a saint be considered having an incorrupt body or not. So today they're no longer considered incorrupt. Okay, zero for one, Caitlin, next one.

Okay, Saint Paula Frascinetti. This is another one. Look at that's morbid. They just have this thing on display like it's a circus or a carnival.

Incorrupt or nan, so her skin looks preserved. It is with carbolic acid, all right, so. No preservation allowed at all. That would make this one a Nah.

It's incorrupt once. Yeah, it's incorrupt. When they first opened up Saint Paula's tomb. Twenty look at this girl too, she's like taking taking selfies near the dead people nice.

Four years after her death, she was looking great and the nuns of her order were thrilled, so thrilled that they had her preserved in carbolic acid. But since this happened after the discovery of her body, she's still considered incorrupt, is that you? And so they preserve the body with carbolic acid. They dug it up and it looked pretty good.

I really, I'm at a loss for this whole, this whole thing, and why they would do these kind of things, like it's morbid to me. Let him be buried and rest in peace, not be gaukd at for are they just going to leave him in there forever and they'll be gualkd at for hundreds or thousands of years? And Saint Paula, yeah, definitely is a nun took the picture. It's fine, she insisted to her.

Yeah, you don't say no to a non zero to two. Saint Julian Imard in Paris that now that looks like another wax body. It's super creepy. That has to just be wax.

So that isn't that is a knap, That is an Now he's incredible, he. Is, he's incorrupted, just like Saint Paula. His church also tried to bathe him in carbolic acid, but it completely backfired and destroyed his body. So the body was destroyed, but they still have it on display somehow.

But what's now left of him is encased in this terrifying way epigy that makes it look like he's been buried alive. Sure makes me feel pious. St. Anthony of Padua Inca.

Oh, this one's interesting. So sometimes it's not an entire body that they declare and corrupt, just a part of the saint, like the head or different pieces as we'll see here. Or nah, is that a body part? Yeah, that's his tongue.

Okay. If this game has taught me. Anything so far, it's that I have to just go against every instinct that I have. So I'm going to say that this is an incorrupt tongue.

You're right, it's a hat, I mean, correctably, one part is incorrupt. Well, the rest he composes normally. Yeah, so that's interesting. Sometimes they just say the heart of that saint is incorrupt, but the rest of the body is just rotting away as a normal human body would.

This is exactly what happened to St. Anthony of Padua when his coffin was open. Only as tongue survived intact, so it was detached and put on display in a reliquary. Points on the incorrupt detached tongue.

Thank you? Ready for the lightning round? Bring it? Here are two skeletons wearing clothes, which one is incorrupt, the.

One on the bottom, No, the one on the top is. The incorrupt skeleton of Saint Francesca Romana. Okay, two brown leather. Yeah, these look like mummies.

These two. These do not look like anything miraculous. It looks like you just put a body on a seat or standing up on a stand and let them just rod away inside your church or cathedral or whatever. Very bodies.

Which one is incorrupt? Well, the one on the left is in a box, which makes me think she's more important. So the one on the left, correct, I'm. Okay, last one ready?

Two wax bodies. This one is extra confusing because they're in the same church. So which one is incorrupt? So this church has two of these bodies?

Awesome, hat, You're. So right. Incorrupt, not me being bitter because I lost or anything. But if it's so random, why is this even still a criteria for sainthood.

Well, this is a big reason why the church doesn't consider incorruptibility a miracle anymore. It used to be that if you were found incorrupt, that could help you become a saint, But today there are just too many padre of those natural explanations for finding bodies in this state. So incorruptibility has been downgraded from miraculous to a favorable sign. A favorable favorable sign.

All right, you're incorrupt. That doesn't mean you're a saint, but it doesn't hurt basically, Well, thank you for coming by to clear nothing up. Elizabeth. You can find more of her photographs and writing on her fantastic blog.

All the Saints you should know, and you should know them. You should, unlike me, who apparently knows none of them. Brought to you the support from People's Memorial Association and the all. Right, so I guess I've proved my point with that video.

I don't I don't trust when they say something is miraculous, because I don't think there's anything miraculous about these these so called incorrupt bodies. We'll take some questions and comments from the lab chat at a little more time to share with you. The only thing that the Shroud proves is that the Roman Empire killed lots of people, kind of like every empire that has existed to this day. Well, that's a very good point, right, And Sherry says it does look like a photograph Stephen left eye, thrashed, knocked out.

Yeah, that's some of those bodies don't look so good. Right, Some of those bodies do not look incorrupt to me. They don't look good at all. All right, one second, I'm catching up to the live chat.

I'm way behind. Apparently you guys are chatting away in there. And before I forget, please do take a moment to like, comment and subscribe here. It really does help.

Hit that subscription. But hit that subscribe button, tap the notification bell. You'll know when we're doing one of these deep dives. And this is just the first of probably many shows on this subject we're going to go through.

I have so many folders here. Have you looked into eucharistic miracles? Yes, and that's another one that I think. There's a lot of fraud and stupidity when it comes to that.

Stephen is a scholar of theology. Yeah, a lot of people don't know this, but I almost became a priest, and I spent some time at Saint Charles Seminary before deciding that the priesthood was not for me. Sam Corbyn is reminding everybody to hit the like button. True secret show.

Are you an atheist? No? I am what most people would call an agnostic. I don't believe in atheism because I just look, I just can't wrap my mind around this universe being so perfect and they're not being at least intelligent design that went into the universe, which would mean there would have to be a designer or what many people would call God.

People are mentioning a Catholic church scandal. How many boys? Yes, the sedlak ostuary. Oh that's another interesting I'm a good Catholic.

I'm no longer a Catholic. I stopped being Catholic for various reasons, but most of them are because I think that the Catholic Church is all about money, and they have proved that to me time and time again. I told this story many times, but a quick version is when my father died. He was in hospice for six months, and then the funeral director called me and said, the church said that they can't do the Mass or give you a priest to bury him.

And I was like, what's going on. He's been in that church for fifty years, like he's volunteered there. Everybody knows who he is, Like, so I have to go to the rectory and I find out they decided he wasn't a Catholic and good standing because he hadn't been to church for six months, they said, and I said, how do you know that, Well, we haven't gotten a church envelope from him. So the long story short, I had to pay twenty dollars a week or something for six months, and then suddenly he was a good Catholic again and they could do the mass and bury um.

It was right then that I decided that I'm not gonna support a church that treats people like that. My father had volunteered at that church for many, many years. He was well known, respected and loved, and for the church to slap my family in the face while we were grieving like that, it didn't sit well with me. And famously I went to the ATM machine and I got out the cash, and I went back to the rectory and I literally threw it in the face of the priest and said, you call that funeral director back as soon as I walk out of here and you finish making the arrangements, you're going to bury my father or you and me and everybody in this rectory are going to have a big fucking problem.

And I did drop an f bob, and interestingly, a different priest came to bury my father, and he was as nice and can be as could be, and he did apologize for the misunderstanding. But by that point the damage is done right and Patty Wilhelm says the cash. Yes, that's interesting, Tolie Toldtul says, I went to a Quaker school, and that's what's wrong with America and the world. Yeah.

I wasn't treated properly. And it was more just my father died rather unexpectedly. He was in. He was in.

They were talking about moving him to like a rehab hospital and that he would more fully recover and even come home. So we were very hopeful that his medical condition was improving, and then he just kind of died suddenly one night. So it was unexpected and you know, very difficult time. And this priest basically shaking me down for money at a time like that, I was so pissed, and I remained pissed for many years.

And then I gave them another chance even after that one, and then the next thing was even worse that they did to my family. So I just said, I hope your church, I said to myself, and I know this is probably sinful and not a good Christian thing, but I remember thinking, I hope your church burns down and you all lose every every financial resource. You have. Something else.

Favorite song of twenty twenty five, I don't know. I'm not real big on newer music. I would have to say my favorite album that I started listening to heavily in twenty twenty five was Ozzy Osbourne Patient number nine. I think it's an incredible album, and I just wish there was more OZSI albums.

But rest in peace, the Prince of Darkness. Thank you for your kindness, generosity and support. Von Schrgan is here with one for the goal. And it would be a terrible show host if I didn't go and check in with the Kickchat.

And I apologize to the Kickchat kind of. When I have to do these longer presentations with all of these different data points, it's very difficult to keep up with the show host stuff, so I apologize. Tampon Blood Magic said a rage quit. Thank you for that.

And I was going to call out some subs or some gifted subs, but it looks like we are doing just okay here. We're all caught up on that. But please do support us of our own kick if you like the streams and want us to continue streaming there. Kick is a tremendous resource for people like me because it gives us an extra paycheck in the month and everybody imagine getting five paychecks for the month next week instead of next month, instead of four.

Kick really does help us with some extra money. And finally, a lot of people have asked me about this Corey Good situation. It's been since December seventh, and I'm still waiting on YouTube to try to resolve the false copyright claims and issues. But I will put on the record that it's pretty ridiculous because mister Good has made many false Here's what I'll say.

He's made many false and defamatory statements in writing, which is a real problem. Like the guys of Moron, he doesn't understand what he just did. He put in writing in these copyright takedown requests that the videos on my channel were stolen and that I've stolen other videos and that he called the police on me. Well, all of those statements are demonstrably easily proven false.

So is it any surprise to me? And by the way, for those unaware those are legal filings and knowingly make making false statements in writing in that legal filing is considered perjury. And this is where we're at. This guy is so stupid that he's telling people I stole videos and I stole other videos, and that the police have been called on me.

Well, we seem to recall another person who claimed I was a criminal. That would be his one time partner, David Wilcox. So it doesn't surprise me that somebody like Corey Good would be both stupid enough, reckless enough, and dumb enough to make completely and totally defamatory false statements that are easily proven false. Show the proof that I stole a video, Show the proof that I stole other videos from other people.

That's what he said essentially in his filings. Show the police report that proves that you called the police on me. Did you call the police on me for stealing a video? Like putting a video on YouTube?

You've called the police over that. Really, I'd love to see the police report. And if he can't produce it, then he made knowingly made false statements to YouTube. And he can try to squirm out of it or worm out of it, but it is what it is.

I will say that you know all of these legal problems that we get, which are really childish and stupid, like you're gonna threaten me with legal shit because we proved you were lying, scumbag, you know, But this is this is what happens. There's a theory that the church impersonated again None called Sister Lucia for approximately fifty years. The evidence is pretty credible. I have seen that.

That is quite the rabbit hole. Right, And Arlene says Old Rock is the best yeah back before digital right and Charlie trolchol with one for the goal. Thank you for your kindness, general city and support, he says for the Legal Defense Fund, Well, it's going to be interesting to see kind of what happens with the whole situation. And I have never Oh we have Gotson Gotsen Hammer gifted a sub So thank you for your kindness, generosity, gots and Hammer.

I hope I'm saying that right, go six t Z six h Hammer six are got sticks. I think it's got stick sex and Hammer. Maybe you can tell me how to say that. But I thank you for your kindness, generosity and support of the show.

It is much much appreciated. Tampa. Blood Magic is over there and plouding in the kicklive chat. Good to see him as well, and we have broken hip.

Has been a member for two months, so thank you for that, and thanks to all of our members. People have asked me how to I become a member. You just small the join button and for a few dollars a month, you get member badge, letting everybody in the live chat know you're a big show supporter, and you get access to our members the only section with many many extra videos, so you get a bunch of extra goodies as well, and we thank you all for that. And failing that, you can join on Patreon for a dollar a month.

You get the same benefits, but you don't get the extra YouTube goodies. So yeah, I'm glad that we started. This is just the start of trying to tackle this subject. And let me know in the live chat.

Put a one if you want to see me interview some experts on the shroud of touring and have some guests that are experts or researchers into the shroud of touring, and too if you don't care to see experts, if you don't want me to do interviews with the experts, it's on this particular subject. And if you have any suggestions for future shows, please put them in all capital letters, and we consider all those things. I have a huge list of shows that people ask me, subjects that people ask me to do shows on Would you want too if you want Wilcock as a guest, I don't think I would want him, but I am seeing a lot of ones, so we'll see if we can't reach out. There's a many people that I suppose you could say are kind of on the podcast circuit that are experts in the shroud of touring or have done many, many years of research.

And if you're interested, there is one website and he's first on my list. There's a gentleman. It's called Shroud Research shr oudresearch dot net, and there is an interesting gentleman there named Bob Rucker. And Bob Rucker has a Bachelor of Science and a master's degree in nuclear engineer from the University of Michigan and professional engineering certificates in nuclear engineering and mechanical engineering.

He worked for thirty eight years in the nuclear industry performing nuclear analysis computer calculations for the design of advanced nuclear reactors. He's one of the big researchers and maybe one of the people who are claiming that it is some form of radiation which created the image on the shroud. I listened to several of his interviews, and he's got some interesting science to back up his belief that the shroud is indeed the genuine burial cloth of Christ. Father Andrew Dalton.

Sure, Father Malachi Martin, Oh, if only I could. That guy's interesting his books. I really liked Malackie Martin's books and his interviews on art bell. Anybody remember those.

That's blast from the past. Father Malachi Martin for those that aware. He was a Catholic priest and also an exorcist. And they made some Hollywood movies and Russell Crowe played him in the latest Hollywood retelling of his story, which was not good.

I think they went a little too Hollywood on that one, right, They got a drama it up, but holy he like they have him shooting a pig in this because he convinced the demon to jump from a human host to the pig and then he shot the pig in the head. It's a whole I didn't like that movie. I think that movie is called The Pope's Exorcist. But it is true that Malickie Martin was a Catholic priest and exorcist, and he was the exorcist for Rome for quite some time.

All right, So I believe, my friends, that we have done our due diligence. I believe I will be back on Thursday night at seven pm Eastern time. But I have to say there's some good news, and that is I'm off another one of these terrible meds that make me drowsy and tired and lethargic, and I'm feeling a lot better, so we may go back to our usual schedule. I'm trying to keep things light for those I'm aware.

You know, I just had a big medical thing happen and I'm slowly feeling like myself again and recovering. And our current schedule is Tuesday, Tuesdays and Thursdays and sometimes a weekend show. And if you get a chance, we did a Kick exclusive show just on Sunday, So go over to our kickchannel. It's Kick dot com Truth Seeker show you'll find us and there is Urban Terror with one for the goal saying great show and subject tonight you didn't have to raise your blood pressure.

That's another part of this equation. It used to be believe it or not. Way back when this show started, Urban Terror, what we would do is we would have like a week's worth of shows that were like tonight's show, kind of like calm and scholarly, a lot of research and a lot to ponder, you know, and a lot of discussion or interviews that were kind of more on the calm side, and then maybe once every couple of weeks there'd be a big blowout show where I'd be yelling and screaming at scumbags and grifthers, and for whatever reason, well I kind of know the reason. Those shows get more attention and get more views.

So I kind of got passively encouraged to be a maniac more. But I'm going to try to get back to, you know, being calm, and you know, I don't know, I don't want to screw up my zen or my health with like I'm supposed to avoid things that raise my blood pressure right now for obvious reasons, and I think a good way to do it is to have some of these more calm shows. But you're right, Urban Terror, thanks for noticing, and we have is yale is yaleo of stuff is a why a lot of stuff. I think that is glad you're doing better.

Thanks for the show. Well, thank you for kindness, generosity and support. Much much appreciated, and we have M three ga princesses. Great show and very good to hear your recovering.

I'm feeling so much better this week than I did in the previous weeks. I guess all that rest helps. I really am trying to take it easy and not do much. Against my better judgment.

I started binge watching Stranger Things, which I completely missed. You know, but I'm one of those late adopters, like I didn't do Game of Thrones until it was years old. I didn't do Breaking Bad until it was years old, or Sopranos until it was years old. Von Schrgan with one for the goal says, oh my god, the goal.

Well, yes, the goal is going to end here, but we got more than halfway there and that's sometimes that's good enough. And Freddy the Cat, thank you for the show. Thank you Von Schrgen for being a member of your kindness, generosity and support. And thank you Freddie the Cat for your kindness, generosity and support.

And Arlene is reminding everybody that the kick only streams how to get to them but if you're a YouTube channel member or a Patreon supporter, I do upload those. I upload all of the kick only shows so you can catch the replay in the member section or on Patreon as well. Otherwise you've got to go over to kick before they I think they only keep the streams for two weeks at my level, and then the shows are deleted and newer shows will be there. In other words, they don't archive every show like YouTube does.

But thank you our lean for your kindness and moderation, best moderator in the game, and thank you for your kindness, generosity and sup for all of you supporters. So we have done our due diligence. Like I said, I should be back on Thursday, but if I'm feeling like I am today, I might get another show off of my I've got a lot of things on my to do list, and tonight was one of them. So thank you for coming here and spending some time with me to explore what I believe is an enduring mystery.

My mind is still not made up. There's some things about this whole thing that just scream something's weird here, right, Like the pollen on the cloth that comes from plants, that is only in Jerusalem's that's a weird one, you know. And there's a great deal of blood evidence, but it's a little data heavy. The science on the blood that was found, and by the way, it is verifiably real human blood is another head scratcher because there's apparently there's blood that was pre mortem blood, there's blood that was post mortem blood, meaning that the body was bleeding while it was alive, and then you know, there was blood that oozed out after the death event.

And both types of blood, both pre mortem and post mortem, have been verifiably found on the on the shround. And if we if we are to believe the skeptics that this is just a hoax, well that's some great lengths to go to get the pollen from plants from Jerusalem. Make sure that the image can be seen like a photograph once it's once you do a photo negative of it, put blood on it from a living person and a dead person. It's it's it's an enduring mystery.

That's why we're here because I'm going to continue to look into this enduring mystery. And there's been a resurgence of interest in the Shroud of touring in the recent years and you'll see that on YouTube. If you just put Shroud of Touring in the search box, you'll see there's lots of Tucker Carlson did a show on this, Piers Morgan. It's becoming a very popularized subject again, so I wanted to dive back into it.

You know, the three D information being embedded on this leads me to believe, like, how does a hoaxer know how to do all of this before in the thirteen hundreds. I would really love to conduct some of my own experiments to see if we can form an image something like the shroud. And I happen to have a life size bust of Jesus kind of digging out. I think it's somewhere in a box, since you know, you ever move and you just never unpacked.

It's just, you know, it's boxes in my garage that were put there the day we moved in, you know. But it would be interesting to see if we can recreate something like the shroud of Touring. And if you guys would like to see that, I'll certainly give it a try. There's various ways that people have tried to reproduce the image, usually with some sort of mask or a sculpture and they pigment the sculpture and then they lay the shroud over it and press, and that creates an imprinted image.

Perhaps it's definitely, it's definitely interesting. And of course being raised Catholic, these kind of things that have always fascinated me, and as a child who was trying to be a good Christian and really wanted to believe that, you know, my religion was true and real, and you know, I would look to these things like relics or like the shroud of tour and as proof that the Bible wasn't just stories, that the Bible was more than that. Right, the crowd was Jacques's demo lay and not Jesus. Stephen the Cambian, Okay, you say so, So we've done our due diligence.

I am going to bounce on out of here. Please follow me on Twitter at Stephen Cambian. If you're listening in audio podcast Lane, we love and appreciate you. But please do go on over to Twitter.

Put truth sickers one word in the search bar. You'll see a strange guy with sunglasses pop up. That would be me. Go to the channel, smash the subscribe button, hit the Notification belt really really does help.

And we love and appreciate you guys in audio podcast LAMB, but you're missing the live and interactive tapings and we love that so we welcome you to be a part of it. So and also if anybody has ideas or suggestions for shows you can and show topics, you can email me at True Secret Show at gmail dot com. So that's all I got for your friends. I hope that this I guess first dive into this enduring mystery was interesting to you.

Thanks for coming here and spending some time with me. No place I would rather be. But that's all I got for your friends. So until next time, my name is Stephen Cambian.

Good night, and God bless all of you. Attempt intimating active intent, buildings and intents, building intended to. Attemt un. Speaking and people coming up a completed span, people past